He asked her why, and the question hung between them for a long time, and when she finally answered, the answer came out in pieces, the way the truth always came out of Brittany, not all at once but in small, reluctant admissions that she tried to dress up as explanations even as she made them. She had been jealous of Renee from the beginning. She had been jealous of the family happiness she saw when she looked through the windows of the Mitchell house on the evenings before Renee died, jealous of the way Darius looked at his wife, jealous of the way he spoke about her, jealous of a love that had not included her and never would. She had told herself, when she first came into their lives, that she was not jealous, that she was only lonely, that she only wanted a family of her own, but the loneliness had curdled into something harder the longer she stayed, and by the time she moved in she had begun to believe a story in which Renee was the obstacle and she was the replacement, and the only thing standing between her and the life she wanted was a six-year-old girl who would not call her Mommy and would not let go of her mother's hair. She had tried, she said, to occupy Renee's place. She had tried to sit in Renee's chair at the table and sleep on Renee's side of the bed and sign the school forms the way Renee used to sign them, and every time Kayla looked at her with her mother's eyes, it was like being told all over again that she was a guest in someone else's house. She had wanted Kayla to forget. She had wanted the curls gone, and the stories gone, and the photographs put away, and the name Renee spoken less and less until it faded, because as long as Kayla remembered, Brittany would always be second, and she had spent her whole life being second, and she could not bear to be second in her own home. Darius listened, and he did not interrupt, and he did not raise his voice, and the calm in his own chest surprised him, because he had expected rage and what he felt instead was something colder and heavier, something closer to grief. He had loved this woman. He had planned to marry her. He had brought her into his daughter's life because he believed she could love the child, and what he was hearing now was that she had never wanted to love the child at all. She had wanted to replace the child's mother, and when the child refused to be replaced, she had punished her for it.
He asked her about the guardianship papers, and at first she tried to deny that she had ever meant anything by them, and then, when he told her he had seen them himself, that he knew she had kept them in the drawer of her nightstand and had shown them to no one, she went quiet in a different way, the way a person goes quiet when the last excuse has been used up. She admitted, finally, that she had once intended to use them. Not to protect Kayla, not to make anything easier for the child, but to gain rights over her, to put her own name on a piece of paper that would make it harder for anyone to question her place in the house. She had imagined, she said, a future in which Darius was grateful, in which the papers were only a formality, in which everyone agreed that she was the mother now and the matter was settled, and she had never once stopped to ask herself what Kayla would have thought of that future, or whether a six-year-old girl who had already lost her mother once should have to lose her again to a piece of paper. Darius thought about the night Renee died, about the promise he had made to her in the hospital room with the machines humming and the light coming in grey through the blinds, the promise that he would keep their daughter safe and that he would keep her mother's memory alive in the house, and he thought about how close he had come to breaking that promise without even knowing it, because he had been so desperate not to be alone that he had handed the keys to a woman who saw his daughter as a rival. He did not say any of that to Brittany. He said only that the lie was over, and that it had not only broken the engagement, which was the least of it, but that it had deepened the pain in both families, hers and his, and that she was going to have to live with that. She flinched at the word families, and he saw it, and he knew why, and that was when he asked her the question he had been carrying since the night before, the question Marcus had told him to ask only if he was certain he wanted the answer. He asked her about her own daughter.