At 10:20, she received a text message. It was not from Preston. It was from Preston's executive assistant, a young man named Graham whom Catherine had met perhaps four times. It said: Mrs. Vance, Mr. Vance has asked me to let you know that both aircraft are committed today. He suggests you book a commercial flight to New York, on a carrier other than Aurelian. Please let me know if you need assistance. Regards, G.
Catherine read the message three times.
Then she put her phone face down on her lap and looked out the window at the empty stand where Flight 247 had been, and for the first time in a very long time, she did not know what to do.
She was fifty-three years old. She had been Mrs. Preston Vance for twenty-six years, and in those twenty-six years, she had never once booked her own flight. She had never stood in a line to change a ticket. She did not know how. There had always been someone to do it for her: an assistant, a travel agent, a house manager, a pilot. She had been very proud of that, once. Now, sitting in a vinyl chair at an empty gate with spilled champagne drying on her jacket, it occurred to her for the first time that it was not, in fact, something to be proud of at all. It simply meant that she had become a person who did not know how to do anything for herself.
She had not always been that person.
Catherine Whitfield had been born in Scranton, Pennsylvania, in 1973, the only daughter of a foreman at a textile mill and a woman who did alterations out of the front room of their row house. She had grown up hearing the hum of her mother's sewing machine at all hours of the day and night, hemming the trousers and taking in the dresses of women from the big houses on the hill in Clarks Summit, women who came to the door in fur coats and handed over their garments without ever stepping inside. Her mother had always said thank you, ma'am, and never once looked them in the eye. And young Catherine, watching from the stairs, had decided very early that she would rather die than spend her life saying thank you, ma'am, to women who didn't look at her.
She had gotten a scholarship to a good college in Philadelphia. She had lost her accent there, deliberately, practicing in front of the mirror at night. She had learned which fork to use and how to talk about art and how to pretend she had always summered somewhere. She had moved to New York and gotten a job at an auction house, and at twenty-seven, at a charity auction for the New York Public Library, she had met Preston Vance, who was thirty-two and already rich and already ruthless, and who had looked at her across the room with exactly the kind of appraising, possessive gaze she had spent her whole life wanting someone to turn on her.
She had thought, for a long time, that she had escaped. That she had climbed up out of the row house and the sewing machine and the women in fur coats on the doorstep, and become one of them.
It had taken her until that morning, sitting in seat 2A, hearing her husband's voice go cold on a speakerphone in front of a cabin full of strangers, to understand that she had not escaped anything at all. She had simply traded one doorstep for another. Her mother had said thank you, ma'am, to women in fur coats. Catherine had spent twenty-six years saying yes, Preston, to a man who looked at her the way those women had looked at her mother. And she had made the people beneath her pay for it. Waiters. Shop clerks. Housekeepers. Flight attendants. Anyone who couldn't fight back.
Danielle Brooks.
She took the boarding pass out of her handbag and turned it over and looked at the name she had written on the back, in her careful, looping cursive. The cursive she had practiced for months in college, because her own handwriting had looked too much like her mother's.
"Ma'am?"
Catherine looked up. The gate agent, the young woman with the friendly face who had scanned her boarding pass that morning, was standing in front of her. Her name tag said Keisha. She was holding a paper cup.
"Mr. Fletcher from the tea stand sent this over," Keisha said. "He said you looked like you could use it. It's chamomile." She held it out. "And I wanted to let you know, I checked, and there's another flight to LaGuardia at 12:15. Flight 249. It's one of ours. Aurelian." She hesitated. "I know you might not want to fly with us. That's totally okay. I can look up other carriers for you. But if you do want it, there's a seat available. I can put you on it at no charge."
Catherine stared at her. "You know what happened," she said. "On the other flight. Everybody must know by now."
Keisha's face didn't change. "Yes, ma'am," she said simply. "Danielle Brooks is my aunt's best friend. I've known her since I was six."
The paper cup of chamomile was warm in Catherine's hands. She looked down at it. Then she looked back up at the young woman in the Aurelian uniform who had just offered, after everything, to put her on a flight for free.
"Why would you do that?" she asked. And her voice, she noticed, was shaking.
Keisha shrugged slightly. "Because it's my job to get people where they're going," she said. "That's all of them. Not just the nice ones." She paused, and then added, a little more softly, "And because Ms. Morgan called me from the airplane, before they pushed back. She asked me to make sure you got to New York safe. She said to take care of you the same as anybody."
Catherine Vance sat very still.
"Is there…" She stopped. She cleared her throat. "Is there a seat in economy?"