It rang five times. She almost hung up. Then a voice answered, thin and cracked and unmistakably Scranton.
"Hello?"
"Mom," Catherine said. "It's me."
There was a long silence. Margaret Whitfield was seventy-nine years old. She still lived in the same row house, and she still did alterations in the front room, though fewer now, because her eyes weren't what they used to be. Her daughter called her on her birthday and at Christmas. Usually. Not always. The last time they had seen each other in person was at Catherine's father's funeral, three years earlier, when Catherine had flown in on the smaller jet and stayed for exactly four hours and spent most of them on her phone.
"Cathy?" her mother said finally. Nobody had called her Cathy in thirty years. "Cathy, is something wrong? Are you sick?"
"No, Mom. I'm not sick." Catherine closed her eyes. "I just… I wanted to hear your voice."
And then, to her own astonishment, she began to tell her mother what had happened. Not all of it. Not at first. She told her about the flight. About the seat. About what she had said to the flight attendant in the galley. She told it badly, in pieces, out of order, and when she got to the part about writing down the flight attendant's name, slowly, so the woman could watch her do it, her voice broke completely, and she had to stop.
Her mother didn't say anything for a while. Catherine could hear the faint hum of a sewing machine in the background. Her mother had been working. At seven o'clock at night, at seventy-nine years old. Of course she had.
"Do you remember Mrs. Kessler?" her mother asked finally. "From up in Clarks Summit? The one with the fox stole?"
Catherine did remember. A tall, thin woman with a narrow face and a fox stole with the little head still on it, the glass eyes staring. She had come to the house every few weeks with a bag of dresses that needed taking in. She had never once stepped inside. She had stood on the doorstep and handed the bag to Catherine's mother through the storm door and said exactly what she wanted done and when she wanted it, and Catherine's mother had said, yes, Mrs. Kessler, thank you, Mrs. Kessler, and closed the door. And once, when Catherine was about nine, Mrs. Kessler had looked past her mother at Catherine on the stairs and said, "Is that your girl? Pity about the teeth." And then left.
"I remember," Catherine said.
"I used to hate that woman," her mother said. "Every time she came to the door, I'd hate her for a week. And then one day, oh, you must have been in college by then, I read in the paper that her husband had died. And it came out that he'd been beating her. For years. Thirty years. Everybody up on the hill knew. Nobody did a thing." The sewing machine had stopped. "And I thought about all those times she stood on my doorstep and talked to me like I was dirt. And I thought, well. She had to talk to somebody like that. She couldn't talk to him that way. So she talked to me."
Catherine pressed her hand against her mouth.
"I'm not saying it made it right," her mother went on. "It didn't make it right. Nothing makes that right. But it made me stop hating her. And it made me sorry I never once asked her in for a cup of coffee." A pause. "Cathy. Is he good to you? Preston?"
Catherine didn't answer. She couldn't.
"That's what I thought," her mother said quietly. "That's what I've always thought."
They talked for an hour and a half. It was the longest conversation they had had in twenty years. At the end of it, Catherine asked whether she could come visit. Next week. For a few days. Her mother was quiet for a moment and then said, in a voice that trembled only a little, "I'll make up your old room."
After she hung up, Catherine sat for a long time on the edge of the bed. Then she opened her handbag and took out a thick envelope that Preston's lawyers had sent her three months ago, and that she had signed without reading, the way she signed everything Preston's lawyers sent her. She had brought it to Atlanta by accident, tucked in among the charity luncheon papers. She opened it now and read it, slowly, every page, for the first time.
It was a trust agreement. For tax reasons that she did not fully understand, Preston had moved a portion of his Aurelian shares into an irrevocable trust in her name. Two point one percent of the company. The trust agreement named her as the sole trustee and the sole beneficiary. It gave her, and only her, the right to vote those shares.
Catherine Vance read that paragraph four times.