"The cameras were her idea," I said to Devon, and my voice sounded rough. "All of it. She put them in four years ago. I thought she was being — I thought it was about burglars."
Devon nodded, and he did not say anything for a moment, and then he said, "Most people put cameras in because they're afraid of strangers, Mr. Alden. The smart ones put them in because they know the truth about their own house. Your wife was one of the smart ones."
He went back up to the attic after that, to check the DVR itself, to make sure the local drive was intact and the seals were unbroken, and Emily went up with him, and I stood at the bottom of the ladder and listened to their voices, low and careful, and I thought about Helen, and about the house, and about the way a structure tells you the truth about itself if you measure it long enough and stop arguing with the measurements.
Emily leaned over the table, reading the screen. "An hour ago," she said. "That's when Peter would have gotten home. That's when she would have told him — " She stopped herself. "That's when someone would have tried."
Devon finished locking the account — new password, two-factor authentication, a recovery email that went to Emily's address and mine and nobody else's — and he printed out the login history on my old printer, which jammed twice and then produced the pages with its usual groan, and he signed each page at the bottom in his neat hand, with the date and time, and he said, "That's your chain of custody, right there. Keep it with the drives."
He packed his case, and at the door he stopped and looked back at the hallway camera, and then at me.
"Mr. Alden," he said, "whatever's on that drive, I hope it gives you what you need. Most people never get that."
After he left, Emily and I stood in the kitchen with the two drives on the table and the printed pages beside them, and the house was very quiet, and I realized I had been holding my breath since the airport, and I let it out all at once, and my hands were shaking, and Emily put her hand over mine on the table and said, "Dad. Breathe. We've got it now. Nobody can take it."
I looked at the drives, at her hand on mine, at the kitchen where Helen had cooked ten thousand meals, and I said, "I know. It's just — I keep thinking about your mother putting those cameras in. She never told me why, not really. She said, a house should be able to tell you what happened in it. I thought she meant burglars."
"She meant this," Emily said. "She meant exactly this. She just couldn't say it yet."
We were still standing there when the doorbell rang.
Peter was on the porch, alone, in the jacket he wears to church, and his face was the face of a man who had been given a story and told to deliver it, and who did not entirely believe the story himself but had decided to deliver it anyway. He had his hands in his pockets. He would not look at the hallway camera. He looked at his shoes, and then at Emily, and then at me, and he said, "Dad. Can we talk?"
"Come in," I said.
He came in and stood in the hallway, and the camera above the door blinked its small red light, and he glanced up at it once, quickly, and then away, as if it were a sun he had been told not to look at. Rachel's first rule, I thought. Don't watch the camera. And then her second rule, which I had only just begun to understand: if you do watch it, say it's lying.
"Dad," Peter said, "Rachel told me you found something. Something on the cameras. And I — we — think you might be misreading it. The footage is old, Dad. Some of it's four years old. You know how that AI stuff works now. You can make a video say anything. Rachel says — "
"Rachel says," I repeated, and I heard the flatness in my own voice, and I was ashamed of it and could not change it.
He flushed. "She's worried about you, Dad. We both are. You're grieving. You're alone in this house. You're — you're seeing things that aren't there. The night she says you shoved her — Dad, you know you didn't shove her, and she knows it too, she was just scared, she was — "
"Peter," I said. "Stop."
He stopped. He looked at Emily, and Emily looked at him with an expression I had never seen on my daughter's face before, not even when she was fourteen and he had broken her favorite record and she had decided, for a week, that he was dead to her. It was not anger. It was grief, wearing anger's clothes because grief had nowhere else to go.