Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Good. Do not share the exact location with anyone except me for now. I'll need to consult my supervisor and determine how we can secure the site without tipping off the county."

"What if the ledger is there and someone moves it before you can get a warrant?"

"Then we'll have to act quickly, but we still need to do this properly. If we rush in without a plan, we risk destroying evidence or alerting whoever is watching the depot."

Olivia looked through the windshield. Granger had disappeared among the parked cars.

"I don't want another fifteen years to pass."

"I understand. But we won't solve this by making the same mistakes the people before us made."

Rachel ended the call after confirming that an agent was on the way.

Olivia remained in the locked car, watching the library. A few minutes later, her phone vibrated with a message from an unknown number.

You should have stayed away from the past.

She photographed the message and sent it to Rachel.

Another message arrived before she could put the phone down.

Hale is not the only person who knows where the ledger is.

Olivia stared at the words.

A third message appeared.

Ask what happened to Thomas Avery's daughter.

She felt a sudden chill that had nothing to do with the weather.

Thomas had a daughter. Hale had mentioned that his wife and daughter left Willow Creek shortly after his disappearance, but he had not said where they went or whether they were still alive.

Olivia typed a reply, then stopped. She had no idea who was on the other end. Any response might encourage the sender or reveal that the message had frightened her.

Instead, she captured screenshots and forwarded them to Rachel.

The agent called back immediately.

"Do not respond," Rachel said. "We will preserve the messages and see whether the number provides any useful information. Are you still at the library?"

"Yes."

"Stay there until the agent reaches you."

Olivia looked at the message again.

Ask what happened to Thomas Avery's daughter.

The sender knew what Hale had told her. Or perhaps the sender had known about Thomas's daughter long before Olivia ever arrived in town.

If Granger had been watching the meeting, he might have heard enough to understand that Hale had spoken. But the messages were phrased as if the sender wanted Olivia to continue investigating, perhaps toward a new lead. That could be a genuine attempt to help, a deliberate effort to distract her, or a way to draw her into another trap.

She put the phone face down.

Ten minutes later, a dark SUV pulled into the space beside her car. A woman in plain clothes stepped out, showed Olivia an identification card through the window, and waited for her to lower it slightly.

"Agent Morgan sent me," the woman said. "My name is Elena Ruiz."

Olivia unlocked the door but did not open it until Ruiz stepped back.

"Did you find Hale?"

"We're checking the area. Another team is looking at the side streets and nearby parking lots. We don't have confirmation of his location yet."

"Granger was here."

"I know. Rachel told me. She wants you to return to Willow Creek with me, but we'll take a different route and stop somewhere secure first."

Olivia hesitated.

"What about the ledger?"

"Agent Morgan is coordinating with her supervisor. She'll contact you as soon as there's a plan."

"Can you guarantee the county won't get there first?"

"No," Ruiz said honestly. "I can guarantee that we're treating the information seriously."

Olivia appreciated the answer, though it did nothing to quiet her anxiety.

She gathered her notebook, photograph, and the envelope containing the drawing. Ruiz watched the surrounding area while Olivia transferred to the SUV. They left the square without using the main road and drove toward a small state office several miles from town.

For the first time since she had arrived in Willow Creek, Olivia allowed herself to consider the possibility that the truth might be close enough to touch.

And that the people who had buried it might be willing to do almost anything to keep it buried.


By the time Olivia reached the state office, the afternoon had begun to darken. Rain clouds gathered over the hills, turning the sky a dull slate color. Agent Ruiz escorted her to a small conference room and asked her to write down everything Hale had said while the details were still fresh.

Olivia spent nearly an hour reconstructing the conversation. She described the contract, the missing ledger, the meeting at the emergency services building, and Granger's appearance at the library. She documented the exact wording of the threatening messages and provided the photograph of the old depot drawing.

When she finished, Ruiz read through the statement carefully.

"Agent Morgan will want to speak with you directly," she said. "But I need to ask one question before she arrives."

"Go ahead."

"Did Hale tell you that the ledger was definitely still at the depot?"

"No. He said Thomas had used the depot as a hiding place. He hasn't seen the ledger in fifteen years, and he doesn't know whether the location is still secure."

"Did he say what the package looked like?"

"No."

"Did he know the exact date it was hidden?"

"He said Thomas mailed him the drawing about a month after my father's death. He didn't give me an exact date."

Ruiz nodded and wrote something in her notes.

"That's important. We need to distinguish what Hale directly witnessed from what Thomas told him. If we locate the depot, we may find something useful, but we cannot assume it will be the ledger."

"Could the county have demolished the platform?"

"It's possible. We'll check the property records and recent aerial photographs. We may be able to determine whether the maintenance compartment still exists."

"Could we get a warrant today?"

"That depends on the evidence and the authority we have. If the depot is privately owned or controlled by another agency, we'll need to establish the legal basis for a search. We don't want to create a procedural problem that could undermine anything we find."

Olivia looked at the rain gathering beyond the window.

"Every time we get close to something, we have to wait."

Ruiz did not take offense.

"Waiting can be frustrating. But an investigation isn't a race to reach a location first. It's a process of establishing what happened in a way that can withstand scrutiny."

"What if the other side doesn't care about scrutiny?"

"Then we make sure they cannot use our mistakes against us."

The door opened, and Rachel Morgan entered carrying a thin folder. She looked tired, but her expression was focused.

"Olivia, I'm glad you're safe."

"Did you find Hale?"

Rachel shook her head.

"We have a possible sighting of him at a fuel station outside Fairmont. A witness described an older man in a brown jacket leaving in a dark pickup truck. We haven't confirmed the plate. The vehicle may belong to him, but we're still checking."

"Could Granger have followed him?"

"Possibly. We don't know whether they interacted. We're searching the available traffic footage and asking nearby businesses whether they saw anything unusual."

Rachel sat across from Olivia.

"I've also spoken with Judge Hargrove. He found the reference to the missing briefcase."

Olivia leaned forward.

"What did it say?"

"The old court file contains a property receipt attached to the initial accident investigation. It lists several items recovered from your father's vehicle: a wallet, a wristwatch, a set of keys, loose papers, and one locked briefcase. The briefcase was marked for transfer to the county evidence room pending examination."

"Was it ever examined?"

"There's no examination report in the surviving file."

"Was it ever returned to my family?"

"No receipt indicates that it was. There is also no signed transfer record showing that it reached the evidence room."

Olivia felt anger rise again.

"So it simply disappeared."

"From the surviving records, yes. But we're not going to assume it was deliberately removed until we find more information. The original evidence log may have been stored separately."

"Who signed the property receipt?"

Rachel opened the folder and turned it toward her.

"Daniel Whitmore."

Olivia stared at the name.

"Of course."

"He was a deputy at the time. According to the file, he assisted at the crash scene and signed the inventory of recovered property. He also signed the initial incident report."

"Was that normal?"

"It isn't unusual for an officer at a scene to document recovered property. What's unusual is the absence of a complete chain of custody afterward. A locked briefcase is not an item that should vanish from a record without an explanation."

"What could have been inside it?"

"We don't know. But if your father was carrying financial documents, the briefcase might have contained copies of the contracts or his own notes."

"Or the ledger."

"Possibly. Though Hale believes Thomas took the original ledger before your father died."

Olivia thought about the note on the photograph. Bring the original. Had Michael taken the ledger from the depot and placed it in the briefcase? Had he recovered it after Thomas moved it? Or had the briefcase contained evidence that could have led investigators to the original?

The questions seemed to multiply with every answer.

"Can we get the evidence log?" she asked.

"We've requested access to the county's surviving archives. We're also checking whether the state patrol maintained a separate file. The crash happened on a county road, but another agency may have responded or assisted with traffic control."

"How long will that take?"

"I can't promise a timeline. But the request has been escalated."

News in the same category

Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

20 Part