Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Olivia pressed her palms against the table.

"Rachel, someone sent me messages after the meeting. They told me Hale wasn't the only person who knew where the ledger was. Then they told me to ask what happened to Thomas Avery's daughter."

Rachel glanced at Ruiz.

"Have you heard anything about her?"

"Only what Hale told me. She left Willow Creek with her mother after Thomas disappeared."

"Do you know her name?"

"No. Hale didn't say."

Rachel made a note.

"We'll start with public records and the original family address. We may be able to trace a forwarding address, school records, or a name change. But we need to be careful not to expose her to anyone who might still be interested in Thomas."

"Do you think she's in danger?"

"I don't know. The message could be intended to frighten you or point you toward a legitimate lead. Until we know who sent it, we treat it as unverified information."

Olivia looked down at the drawing.

"How soon can we search the depot?"

Rachel leaned back slightly.

"I'm hoping we can establish jurisdiction and obtain the necessary authorization by tomorrow morning. If the location is as Hale described, the property may be controlled by the railway authority or a private owner. We'll check that first. In the meantime, you are not going there."

"I wasn't planning to."

Rachel gave her a look that suggested she was not entirely convinced.

"I mean it, Olivia. If the ledger is there, it may be evidence in a criminal investigation. We need to preserve it properly. If someone is watching the depot, an unauthorized visit could alert them."

"I understand."

"Good. Because I also need you to understand that your safety is part of this investigation. If someone is trying to use you to locate evidence, we cannot let them turn you into a messenger."

Olivia sat silently for a moment.

"What happens if Hale disappears again?"

"We continue looking for him. He has already provided useful information, and we'll do everything we can to locate him safely."

"And if he's lying?"

"Then we test his statements against the evidence. A lead isn't a conclusion."

Rachel closed the folder.

"I have one more update. Maya Collins contacted me. She reached Leonard Price, the retired fire investigator who handled Martin Sloane's house fire."

Olivia straightened.

"What did he say?"

"He agreed to a preliminary conversation, but he wants to meet in person. He said there are details about the fire that were never included in the public report."

"Why?"

"He didn't explain over the phone. He asked whether we could meet him at a location outside Willow Creek tomorrow afternoon."

"Did he know about Hale?"

"No. Maya contacted him about the fire before she knew Hale had approached you. We are treating these as separate leads until the evidence connects them."

Olivia felt a flicker of hope.

"If Price knows something about the fire, he may know whether Sloane was killed to protect the contracts."

"He may. But we won't put words in his mouth. We'll ask what he observed, what he documented, and why the report was handled as it was."

Rachel stood.

"For tonight, you're staying somewhere secure. Ruiz will take you to a hotel under the state's arrangements. We will not tell the county where you are."

Olivia almost protested. She did not want to be moved from place to place like a witness in a case she barely understood. But she also remembered the dark sedan outside her rental house and Granger's appearance in Fairmont.

"Can I call Maya?"

"Yes. Tell her you're safe, but don't share the hotel location. Ask her to preserve all messages and communications related to the story."

"And Judge Hargrove?"

"I'll speak with him. He should avoid contacting the sheriff's office about the missing briefcase until we've secured the relevant records."

Olivia gathered her belongings.

As she rose, Rachel placed a hand on the folder.

"One last thing. You said Hale told you your father had made a separate record of the transactions. Have you searched his personal belongings?"

"Only the family Bible and the papers I brought from home. I haven't had access to all his old things in years."

"Where are they?"

"My mother kept most of them in storage after we moved. Some may still be in boxes at my aunt's house."

"Can you contact your aunt and ask whether she has any of your father's documents?"

"Yes."

"Do that when you're settled. But don't tell her about the depot or the ledger yet. Simply ask whether she remembers any notebooks, account books, or folders he kept at home."

Olivia nodded.

The idea of searching through her father's old belongings filled her with a mixture of dread and longing. For years, she had avoided opening the boxes because she feared finding nothing more than receipts, old photographs, and fragments of a life cut short. Now those fragments might contain the one thing everyone else had failed to find.

As Ruiz escorted her from the building, Rachel called after her.

"Olivia."

She turned.

"We're closer than we were yesterday. That doesn't mean we're safe, and it doesn't mean we have the whole story. But we have witnesses, records, and a lead on physical evidence. Keep your head clear."

Olivia nodded.

"I will."

Outside, the rain had begun.


The hotel was a modest place on the outskirts of a neighboring town, far enough from Willow Creek to avoid the obvious routes but close enough for Rachel's team to reach her quickly. Olivia was given a room on the second floor, with a view of the parking lot and the low hills beyond it. Ruiz checked the door, showed her the emergency contact procedure, and promised to remain nearby until the evening shift took over.

For the first time all day, Olivia was alone.

She sat on the edge of the bed and called her aunt, Margaret Bennett.

Margaret answered after several rings.

"Olivia? Is everything all right?"

"Yes. I'm sorry to call so late."

"It's not late. I was watching television. What's wrong?"

Olivia had rehearsed the question during the drive, but now that she heard her aunt's voice, the words felt more difficult.

"I'm going through Dad's old things. Do you remember whether Mom kept any of his notebooks or work papers after he died?"

Margaret fell silent.

"Why are you asking?"

"I'm trying to organize some family records. I found a few old documents, and I wondered whether there might be more."

"Your mother kept some things for years. She had a box in the hall closet, and I think she moved it when she downsized. But after she died, I helped sort through the house. Most of the ordinary papers went to recycling. I kept a few photographs and letters."

"Did you keep anything from his work?"

"I don't remember. There was a folder with tax papers, perhaps. Why?"

Olivia took a breath.

"I'm looking into the circumstances of his death."

The silence on the line became heavier.

"Olivia," Margaret said softly, "I thought you had put that behind you."

"I tried."

"Your mother never wanted you to keep reopening it."

"Did she ever tell you why?"

"No. She was devastated. She didn't want to discuss the accident. I thought she was trying to protect you."

"Did she ever say that someone had threatened Dad?"

"No."

"Did she ever mention a briefcase he was carrying?"

Margaret's breathing changed.

"Why would you ask that?"

"Because the official records say a briefcase was recovered from his car, but no one can explain what happened to it."

"Oh, sweetheart."

Margaret's voice trembled.

"What is it?" Olivia asked.

"I remember a briefcase. I remember your mother asking the sheriff's office about it after the funeral. She wanted his papers back. They told her there had been nothing important inside, that everything had been processed. She was upset because they wouldn't tell her where the case was."

Olivia sat very still.

"She asked them directly?"

"Yes. She went to the office more than once. I remember because I drove her the second time. A man at the front desk told her that the case had been transferred and that the paperwork would be sent later. It never was."

"Was the man Whitmore?"

"I don't know. It was a long time ago. He was younger than the sheriff is now, and he wore a uniform. Your mother came out looking pale. She said they were treating her like she was asking for something she had no right to have."

"Did she tell you what she thought was inside?"

"She said your father had been carrying work papers. She thought the briefcase contained his account books and a few personal documents. She was angry because no one would return them."

"Did she ever receive anything?"

"Some clothes, his watch, and his wallet. I remember the watch because she kept it in a small wooden box. But I don't recall any briefcase."

Olivia closed her eyes.

"Do you still have the box?"

"I think so. It's in the attic. I haven't opened it in years."

"Could you look for it?"

"I can. But tell me what's happening. You're frightening me."

Olivia struggled to find words that would not alarm her aunt while still respecting the truth.

"I've found evidence that the investigation into Dad's death may have been mishandled. The state is reviewing some of the records. I'm trying to locate documents that could help them understand what happened."

"Are you safe?"

"I'm being careful."

"That's not what I asked."

Olivia swallowed.

"I'm safe right now. The state has assigned someone to help me."

News in the same category

Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

20 Part