Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Can you look at the other papers?" she asked her aunt. "Please don't throw anything away. If you find notebooks or documents with numbers, dates, company names, or signatures, take pictures of them before moving anything."

"Olivia, what is all this?"

"I think Dad may have kept records at home that no one knew about."

"Why would he hide them from your mother?"

"Maybe he wasn't hiding them from her. Maybe he was hiding them from someone else."

Margaret was quiet.

"I remember your father putting papers in that box," she said. "He told your mother they were personal records. I thought he meant tax returns or bank statements. I never imagined it could be anything more."

"Did Mom know about the box?"

"Yes. She knew it existed. But after he died, she didn't want to look at his work papers. She said they belonged to the investigation."

"Did she ever tell the sheriff's office about it?"

"I don't think so. The box stayed in the closet for years. When your mother moved, I must have packed it without realizing what it contained."

Olivia felt a strange rush of gratitude. The box had survived not because someone had deliberately protected it, but because it had been ordinary enough to escape notice.

"Can you keep it somewhere safe for now?"

"I'll put it in my locked study."

"Don't let anyone take it. If someone asks about it, call me first."

Margaret's voice grew anxious.

"Do you think someone might come here?"

"I don't know. But I'd rather be careful."

After they ended the call, Olivia forwarded the photograph to Rachel and waited.

The response came within minutes.

Do not attempt to identify the man yourself or contact anyone based on the photograph. We will compare it with available records. Preserve the original image and ask your aunt to leave the box intact until we can arrange a proper review.

Olivia typed a quick acknowledgment.

She had been about to ask her aunt to scan every document and send the files, but Rachel was right. The box might contain evidence that needed to be preserved. Even if Olivia could read the papers, she could not establish their authenticity or document their chain of custody. She needed to resist the temptation to rush ahead.

At nine, she met Rachel in a conference room at the state office.

The agent had printed the photograph and placed it beside an enlarged image of the courthouse group picture with the scratched-out face.

"Look at the ears, the chin, and the scar," Rachel said. "The images aren't clear enough for a positive identification, but the man may be the same person."

"Can you identify him?"

"Not yet. We're comparing the photographs with personnel records from the county administration and the emergency services department. If he worked there, there may be a staff directory or an old identification photograph."

"Could he have been a contractor?"

"Yes. We won't limit the search to county employees."

Rachel turned to another page.

"We also found something interesting in the property records. The old emergency services building was not the only place used to store county documents. During a renovation in the year before your father's death, several boxes were temporarily moved to a storage facility near the rail depot."

Olivia felt her pulse quicken.

"Was the ledger among them?"

"We don't know. The inventory list is incomplete. But the timing overlaps with the period when Thomas Avery first reported irregularities."

"Could someone have removed the ledger during the move?"

"That's one possibility. The records show that the boxes were checked in and out by different staff members. Several signatures are missing, and one page of the inventory appears to have been replaced."

"Who was responsible for the storage facility?"

"The county contracted with a private records service. The company dissolved several years later. We're looking for its former employees."

Olivia thought of the third man in the photograph.

"Could he have worked for that company?"

"Possibly. The photograph may help us identify him."

Rachel opened a folder containing a timeline.

"There's another development. The state patrol has located a partial dispatch record from the night your father died. It confirms that a second call was placed from a roadside telephone several minutes before the first emergency unit arrived."

"Who made the call?"

"We don't know. The caller reported a vehicle off the road, but the transcript is incomplete. The dispatch operator noted that the caller refused to provide a name."

"Could it have been someone who caused the crash?"

"Possibly. It could also have been a passerby who didn't want to get involved. We need to locate the operator who handled the call, if they're still alive, and determine whether any additional records survive."

Olivia leaned forward.

"Was the call made before or after the time recorded on the county report?"

"Several minutes before the official arrival time. But the county report lists the time of the initial dispatch differently. The discrepancies may be clerical, or they may indicate that the timeline was altered."

"Whitmore signed the report."

"Yes."

"Could he have changed the time to make the crash appear to have happened later?"

"That's a question we need to investigate. We have no proof of that yet."

Olivia looked at the timeline. Each line seemed ordinary on its own. Together, they suggested a series of decisions made by people who knew that accurate records could reveal more than they wanted anyone to see.

"Can we identify the caller?"

"We're trying. The roadside telephone was removed years ago, but the state patrol retained some paper records. There may be a log of calls made from the station that night."

Rachel paused.

"There's also something you should know about Thomas Avery's daughter. We found a likely match in school records. Her name was listed as Rebecca Avery, but she later appears to have used the surname Bell. We have not confirmed that she is the same person. She would be in her late twenties or early thirties now."

"Do you have an address?"

"An old address in another state. It may be outdated. We're checking whether she is still there before making contact."

"Why did the sender tell me to ask about her?"

"That remains unclear. She may have seen something, or the sender may believe she has information about her father's disappearance. It could also be an attempt to manipulate you."

"Would she have been old enough to remember what happened?"

"Depending on her exact age, possibly. But we don't know whether she witnessed anything."

Olivia looked at the photograph of Thomas.

"Her father disappeared. Her mother left town. If someone came looking for him, she may have grown up with the same unanswered questions I did."

"That's possible," Rachel said. "But we have to respect the fact that she may not want to be involved. If we locate her, we'll approach carefully."

Olivia nodded.

"Do you think Thomas is still alive?"

Rachel did not answer immediately.

"We have no death record for him, but that doesn't establish that he's alive. His disappearance was unusual, and the lack of a documented destination makes it difficult to trace. We will search for him, but we won't assume the outcome."

Olivia had been afraid to ask the question. Hearing the answer did not make it easier.

If Thomas was alive, he might be the only person who could explain exactly what had happened to the ledger. If he was dead, then the last remaining trail might lead through his daughter, Hale's memories, and the documents hidden in the old box.

Either way, the truth had survived in fragments.

Rachel gathered the papers.

"We're going to the depot as soon as the property authorization is complete. Meanwhile, I want you to review the photograph and the documents your aunt found only with an investigator present. We need to avoid contaminating anything that could be used as evidence."

"Can I at least read the notebooks?"

"Yes, once we've documented them. If they contain private family information unrelated to the case, we'll keep that separate. We are not interested in searching your father's life for its own sake. We're interested in the evidence relevant to his death and the financial scheme."

Olivia appreciated the distinction.

She had spent the last day feeling as though her father's entire life had been transformed into a crime scene. It mattered to her that he remained a person, not merely a collection of papers and unanswered questions.

"What about Maya and Leonard Price?" she asked.

"Agent Ruiz will accompany them to the meeting. You can join by arrangement, but I would prefer you not be the first person Price sees. He may feel more comfortable speaking with someone who wasn't personally connected to Michael."

"I understand."

"Once he has given his account, we can decide whether you should speak with him directly."

Olivia stood.

"Then let's find out what he knows."


Leonard Price lived in a small house at the edge of a town called Ashford, where the streets were lined with old maples and the yards were separated by low wooden fences. He had retired from the state fire investigation service six years earlier and now spent most of his time repairing antique clocks and volunteering at a community center.

When Maya Collins arrived with Agent Ruiz, Price was waiting on the front porch. He was a compact man in his late sixties, with silver hair, thick glasses, and the wary expression of someone who had learned to distrust official explanations.

He invited them inside.

News in the same category

Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

20 Part