Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Then she made a separate list of everything she would take to Fairmont Public Library: her phone, a small notebook, the copies of the financial records, and a printed photograph of her father and Thomas Avery. She decided against bringing the original family Bible. If the meeting turned dangerous, she did not want to risk losing the one object that had survived her father's death and carried his handwritten warning.

At four, she finally lay down on the sofa, still wearing her clothes. She slept for perhaps forty minutes.

When she woke, the room was filled with gray morning light.

Her phone was vibrating.

Rachel had replied.

I have a preliminary confirmation that Robert Hale was the county emergency services director during the relevant period. I am checking current contact information and will coordinate with my supervisor before noon. Do not go to Fairmont without speaking to me first.

Olivia read the message twice. She typed a reply asking whether Rachel had found anything about Thomas Avery, then set the phone down and went to wash her face.

She was halfway through making breakfast when it rang again.

This time the number belonged to Maya Collins.

"Tell me you're still alive," Maya said when Olivia answered.

Olivia almost smiled. "Good morning to you, too."

"I saw a vehicle parked outside your rental house last night."

Olivia's hand tightened around the phone. "What kind of vehicle?"

"Dark sedan. No front plate that I could see. It was there when I drove past at about eight thirty. I circled the block, and it was gone by the time I came around again."

"Did you see who was driving?"

"No. I didn't stop. After what happened at the courthouse, I figured the last thing you needed was another person walking straight into a situation without thinking."

"That might be the most sensible thing anyone has said to me since I arrived."

"Don't sound so surprised."

Maya's attempt at humor faded quickly. "Olivia, I need to tell you something else. I found an old newspaper clipping about the fire that killed Martin Sloane. It was reported as an accidental electrical fire. The article was barely two hundred words. No photograph, no follow-up, no interviews with neighbors. The fire department's public statement said the house was already heavily involved when the first unit arrived."

"Did the report mention where the fire started?"

"The back of the house, near a utility room. But here's the strange part: the county's emergency dispatch log for that night is incomplete. The surviving record has a call time, a dispatch time, and an arrival time. The narrative field is blank."

"Could that be a routine records problem?"

"It could. But I checked three other house fires from the same year. Their dispatch narratives are intact. Only Sloane's is missing."

Olivia looked down at the documents on the table.

"Did you find anything about the investigation?"

"Only that the state fire investigator's report was never attached to the county archive. I asked a clerk where it might be. She said the county had transferred older fire records to an off-site storage facility years ago, but she couldn't tell me which boxes contained which reports."

"Could we request the report?"

"We can try. The question is whether someone has already made sure we can't find it."

Olivia told Maya about Robert Hale's call, leaving out nothing about the proposed meeting.

For several seconds, Maya said nothing.

"You can't go alone," she finally said.

"Rachel has already told me that."

"Good. For once, listen to the professionals."

"I'm waiting for Rachel to confirm the plan."

"Then wait. And if you do go, keep your phone charged and tell someone exactly where you'll be."

"I will."

"Olivia, I mean it. The man who called you might be telling the truth, but he could also be trying to find out what you know. Or he might be trying to draw you away from Willow Creek."

"I know."

"No, I don't think you do. You grew up here, and your father died here. That makes this personal. Personal is understandable, but it can make you vulnerable."

Olivia glanced at the photograph of Michael beside the family Bible.

"Maybe," she said. "But the fact that it's personal doesn't make the evidence less real."

"I didn't say it did."

Maya exhaled. "I'm going to the newspaper office. I'll keep digging into the fire and the missing briefcase. If Hale is real, I want to know why a former director stayed silent for fifteen years."

"So do I."

They ended the call.

Olivia returned to the table and studied the old photograph again. Her father stood on the left, looking directly at the camera. Thomas Avery stood beside him, thinner than Michael, with a narrow face and an expression that suggested he had not wanted his picture taken. Behind them stood another man, his features partially obscured by the shadow of the building's awning. Daniel Whitmore was unmistakable even at that age. His hair was darker, his jaw less severe, but the set of his shoulders was the same.

On the back, her father's handwriting remained clear.

Friday. 7:40 p.m. Bring the original.

She had assumed the note referred to the ledger. But what if it referred to something else? The wording suggested a meeting, perhaps one in which the original document would be exchanged. If Michael had possessed the ledger, why would Thomas have needed to take it? Had Michael given it to him for safekeeping? Had Thomas stolen it because he feared what would happen if it remained with Michael? Or had the two men agreed to move it because they believed the danger had become immediate?

The photograph had been taken outside the emergency services building. Perhaps that was where the meeting took place.

But the building had been demolished twelve years earlier, and any surviving records about its use had been scattered through county departments. If the meeting had happened on the Friday before Michael's death, then the time might have been significant.

Olivia searched her father's accident report once more. The crash had occurred shortly before midnight on a Friday.

She stared at the time.

7:40 p.m.

Less than five hours separated the meeting noted on the photograph and the crash that killed him.

A chill moved through her.

She picked up the phone and called Rachel.

The agent answered on the fourth ring.

"I was about to contact you," Rachel said. "I have a preliminary plan, but before I explain it, tell me what you've found."

Olivia described the photograph, the note on its back, and the timing of the crash.

Rachel listened without interrupting.

"That's significant," she said when Olivia finished. "Not conclusive, but significant. We need the original crash timeline, not just the summary. If the state has an archived copy, I'll request it."

"What about Hale?"

"I'm still verifying his current address and contact details. The name checks out, but I want confirmation that the person who called you is actually him. I've contacted an investigator who worked on a later county audit. He may know whether Hale is still alive and where he went after retiring."

"He specifically told me to meet him at noon."

"I understand. I'm not telling you to ignore the meeting. I'm telling you not to treat his identity as confirmed yet."

"Can you arrange surveillance?"

"I'm discussing that with my supervisor. If we proceed, we will do it carefully. You will not approach him alone, and you will not follow him if he leaves. You will not chase anyone, confront anyone, or attempt to recover evidence yourself. If something feels wrong, you leave."

Olivia looked toward the window.

"And if Hale refuses to speak unless I'm alone?"

"Then we reconsider the meeting. A person who genuinely wants to help should understand why we need to protect everyone involved."

"What if he thinks he can't trust the authorities?"

"That possibility is real. If he spent years watching the county bury evidence, he may not trust anyone wearing a badge. But that doesn't mean we abandon basic precautions."

Rachel paused.

"One more thing. Do you have any idea how the caller obtained your number?"

"No."

"Did you give it to anyone in Willow Creek?"

"Only you, Maya, and Judge Hargrove. I used it when I contacted the county archive, but that was through an online form."

"That may be enough to explain it. Still, we need to establish whether the number was obtained from a public source or from someone who has access to private records."

"Could Whitmore have arranged the call?"

"He could have. Someone else could have. We don't have evidence either way."

Olivia appreciated that Rachel refused to pretend uncertainty was certainty. In Willow Creek, people seemed to have spent fifteen years choosing the most convenient explanation. Rachel, at least, was willing to leave a question unanswered until she had proof.

"I'll wait for your confirmation," Olivia said.

"Good. Keep your doors locked. Don't confront the sheriff. And if anyone approaches you, document what happens without putting yourself at risk."

After the call, Olivia showered, changed, and tried to force herself to eat. She managed half a piece of toast before her appetite disappeared.

At nine fifteen, she drove to the public parking lot behind the county courthouse. She did not intend to enter the building. She simply wanted to see whether the place looked different in daylight, whether the incident from the previous afternoon had changed anything, whether the people who had watched Whitmore grab her had begun to speak.

News in the same category

Sheriff Grabbed a Woman on a Quiet Street — Then Black SUVs Arrived and His Entire Department Went Silent

20 Part