"What you will find," Elias said, "is a fence built in 1998 by the previous owner's husband. But walk it. Take your time. There is coffee when you are done."
The inspector walked it. He measured. He photographed. He came back around the side of the house with his clipboard under his arm and the expression of a man whose morning has been spent on a errand he cannot justify to himself.
"Mr. Grant, your fence is fine," he said. "It is old. Old is not a violation. The setback is right, the line is right, the posts are sound. I am going to write that I found no violation, because I did not find one."
"I appreciate that," Elias said. "Can I ask how the complaint was made?"
"You can ask," the inspector said, and looked at the clipboard, and seemed to decide something. "It came in as a resident concern through the online portal. Anonymous. They usually are, with the portal. The ones with names attached, people think twice. The anonymous ones, people use them like a suggestion box for the apocalypse." He accepted the coffee. He stood in the kitchen doorway so as not to disturb the small feverish person on the couch, who was watching him over the back of it with the solemn attention of a border agent. "I have been out to this street three times this year," he said. "All this address. Fence, drainage, and a report of an unregistered home business in the spring, which I believe was your daughter's lemonade stand."
"She grossed eleven dollars," Elias said. "The county's cut is in a jar on her dresser if you need to seize it."
The inspector laughed, surprised, and then stopped, and looked at him more carefully. "You are taking this well," he said.
"I am taking it on paper," Elias said. "It is not the same thing, but it photographs better."
When the inspector had gone, Elias wrote up the visit in the second folder, the plain one, in his memorandum hand: date, time, the inspector's name, the finding of no violation, the three county visits to this address in one year, all anonymous, all through the portal. He put the inspector's business card in the folder. He did not yet know what a business card could be evidence of. He only knew that a man who kept a file did not throw away the names of witnesses.
There was a second noise complaint in November, and it was the second one that completed the pattern, the way a second point completes a line. The association advised him that a complaint had been received of amplified music and voices at his address on the night of November 9th, a Saturday. On the night of November 9th, Elias had been in Atlanta, at a working group on financial fraud that the division had been promising to send him to for two years, staying in a hotel whose folio he could produce. June had been in Knoxville with Maren's parents, eating her grandmother's dumplings and losing at checkers on purpose, a kindness she had recently developed. The house had been dark. The thermostat log, which he printed, showed the house in its empty setting for three days. The alarm record, which he requested from the company and received, showed the system armed and undisrupted for the whole period, every door and window accounted for, a small electronic witness that never slept and had nothing to report.
He sent it all. The folio, the thermostat log, the alarm record, and a letter that was, for him, almost warm with restraint. It said that the residence had been unoccupied and alarmed on the date in question, that the complaint therefore described events that had not occurred, that this was the second such complaint, the first having been answered with the same documentation in the spring, and that he was requesting, for the second time, that the association withdraw the complaint and note the withdrawal in its records. He sent a copy to Owen, because Owen had told him to write to whoever read the file later, and he had begun to think of Owen as the first of those readers, a kind of advance man for an audience he could not yet see.
The association's reply arrived in eight days and was one paragraph long. It thanked him for the documentation, which would be placed in the property file. It stated that complaints were recorded as received and that the association did not adjudicate the truth of complaints made by residents in good faith. It recorded the matter as closed.