The spring meeting was held on a Tuesday night in April in the library community room, with folding chairs in rows and the pond aerator's budget on a flip chart, and it was attended by thirty-one residents, which was, as everyone present understood, a wartime turnout. Ashford Trace did not attend meetings. Ashford Trace attended this one the way a street attends a fire: in person, quietly, and with its eyes open.
Elias sat in the third row with the Bergstroms on one side of him and an empty chair on the other, because June was at home with Priya and a board game, and because he had decided that he would sit where a resident sits and say what a resident says, no more. He had brought nothing. That was a decision too, and it had cost him an evening of argument with himself at the desk. The second folder, the plain one, with the memoranda and the folios and the inspector's business card, stayed home in the cabinet. He had brought his memory, which was better than the folder, and his patience, which was the folder's whole point.
Vivian presented the measure herself. She stood at the front of the room in the cream suit, with the pearls, with Pruitt seated at the table beside her with the minutes and the water glasses, and she made the case for the compliance escalation provision the way she had made it to Pruitt in February: as housekeeping, as modernization, as a tool the association would probably never need. She spoke of standards. She spoke of the small number of properties that generated a disproportionate share of the association's enforcement burden. She spoke, at last, of the number, and she said it the way she had said it in the study, like a harvest figure.
"One property in this community," she said, "has generated forty-three compliance items in fourteen months. Forty-three. The association did not go looking for them. They accumulated, because that is what happens when a household regards the covenants as optional. This measure simply gives your board the means to address a pattern that the ordinary tools were not designed for."
She did not look at Elias. She looked at the room, over his head, the way a speaker looks at a horizon. It was Renee Castellano who spoke first, from the board table, in the tone of a woman reading an agenda item she has concerns about, which is a tone that has ended more measures than any shout.
"Before we discuss the means," Renee said, "I would like to discuss the number. Forty-three items. I asked the association office for the compliance records for all twenty-six properties for the same period, so the board could see how this property compares. I was told the summary in the packet was the summary approved for distribution. So I will ask in public what I asked on the telephone. Of the forty-three items, how many resulted in a finding of violation by this board?"
The room was very quiet. Pruitt, at the table, was looking at the minutes with the attention of a man defusing something.
"The items are recorded as received and addressed," Vivian said. "The board does not adjudicate each individual complaint. That has never been our practice."
"How many were withdrawn as unfounded?" Renee said.
"Withdrawal is not our practice either."
"How many were answered with documentation that the condition did not exist?" Renee said. "Or that the property was unoccupied on the date in question. I am asking about two noise complaints I have heard about, Vivian. For nights when the house was empty. I would like to know if they are in the forty-three."
"I am not going to litigate individual items in a membership meeting," Vivian said, and her voice, for the first time in Elias's hearing of it, had an edge of the kind that comes not from anger but from a script departing from its lines. "The volume is the fact before this body. The volume is not in dispute."