The Badge in His Pocket

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I intend to," Preston said. "It seems to be the whole of the work." And he hung up, and Elias stood in the kitchen with the bath running upstairs and thought that the sentence was the truest one the Ashford family had produced in fourteen months, and that it had taken the son, and not the mother, to say it.

The outside bookkeeper's review arrived in the mailboxes of Ashford Trace on a plain white paper, in plain white envelopes, in the second week of November, and it was, in its way, the most remarkable document the street had ever received, because it was the first one in seventeen years that had been written to be read.

It was eleven pages long. It covered five years of enforcement activity. It found that in that period the association had directed two hundred and nine compliance items in total, and that one hundred and sixty-one of them had been directed at three properties: the Merritt property at number 9, during the two years preceding its sale; a rental property at number 22, during a tenancy of fourteen months; and the Grant property at number 14, with forty-three items in fourteen months, the highest rate of enforcement activity against a single household in the association's recorded history. It found that of the forty-three items directed at number 14, none had resulted in a finding of violation by the board; that five were contradicted by documentation supplied by the homeowner at the time, including two complaints of noise on dates when the property was verifiably unoccupied; that one was supported by a photograph that depicted the property in a different season than the date of the notice; and that the association's records contained no comparable documentation of conditions at any other property for the same period. It found, in the flat language of bookkeepers, which is the language in which the truth often travels furthest, that enforcement during the period reviewed "was not uniform in application," and it recommended the adoption of written standards for the initiation, documentation, and withdrawal of compliance items, including a requirement that a complaint contradicted by documentation be withdrawn and the withdrawal recorded.

Appended to the review, on the association's new letterhead, which was the old letterhead with a different name at the bottom, was a letter signed by Renee Castellano as president. It said that the board accepted the review's findings and recommendations in full. It said that the association regretted the burden placed on the households identified, and that the board was writing separately to each of them. It did not use the word sorry. Elias read it twice and found that he did not need it to. The findings were the apology, in the only dialect that had ever mattered on that street, which was the dialect of the record, and they had been mailed to all twenty-six houses.

The separate letter to the Grants arrived the following day, in a white envelope, and it was short. It stated that the association withdrew, in their entirety and for the record, the two noise complaints of the previous year, the turf notice supported by the winter photograph, and the commercial vehicle notice, and that the withdrawals had been recorded in the association's minutes; that the remaining items in the property file had been reviewed and were closed without findings; and that the property file for 14 Ashford Trace now consisted, in the association's records, of the review, the withdrawals, and this letter. It was signed by Renee Castellano, President, and beneath her signature, in a hand that Elias recognized from fourteen months of Fridays he had never witnessed, was a second signature, as manager, attesting the minutes: G. Pruitt.

Elias read the letter standing at the mailbox, with the November sun going early and the street doing its evening things around him, doors and dogs and the pond light coming on. He carried it into the house and he put it in the folder, the first folder, the one labeled ASHFORD TRACE HOA, on top of the log that had begun with a welcome letter, and then he took the second folder, the plain one, with the memoranda and the folios and the inspector's business card and the sentence he had written in August about forty-one actions and five demonstrably false, and he put it in the cabinet beside the first, and he closed the cabinet door. The file was complete. It had a beginning and a middle and an end, and the end was a letter in a white envelope withdrawing, in writing, the things that could not have happened. He stood in the spare room for a moment with his hand on the cabinet, a man in his forties with his life's training in the keeping of records, and he understood that he was performing a small private ceremony, and he allowed himself to perform it, because some ceremonies are for the record too, even when the only witness is the man himself.

News in the same category

The Badge in His Pocket

45 Part