"The volume is the only thing not in dispute," Tom Okafor said, from the end of the table, in his logistics voice, mild as milk. "I drove the loop three nights this week and counted the things we write letters about. Bins: six houses. Trucks: four. Lawns past due: five, including mine, and I apologize to the community. In fourteen months I have received one cream envelope, and it was this packet. So when the president says the covenants are applied uniformly, I have a counting problem, and I thought I should bring it to the meeting, because counting is what I am for."
There was a sound in the room then that was not quite a laugh and not quite anything else, the sound of thirty-one people recalculating at once. Elias sat very still and looked at his hands and understood that the street was doing, in public, the thing he had declined to do for fourteen months, and that it was doing it not because of him but because of the arithmetic, which belonged to anyone who cared to do it. He felt, absurdly, the urge to protect the meeting from becoming a brawl, and then he felt Vivian's attention cross the room and find him, and he knew she was going to call on him, because she needed the evening to be about him and not about her count.
"Mr. Grant," she said. "The property in question is yours. Perhaps the membership would like to hear from you."
Every head in the room turned. Elias stood up, because his mother had raised him to stand when a room was listening, and he spoke briefly, and he kept his voice at the level of a man discussing a fence, which in a sense he was.
"Thank you," he said. "I have answered all forty-three items in writing, and I will keep answering them, because that is what the covenants ask and I agreed to the covenants when I bought my house. Two of the items are complaints of noise at my house on nights when the house was empty and alarmed, one in March of last year and one in November. I sent the association the hotel records and the alarm records both times. The complaints are still in the count of forty-three. I would ask the board, before it votes on a measure that counts items, to decide whether an item that could not have happened should count. That is my only comment."
He sat down. He had not raised his voice. He had not mentioned his job, or Maren, or the lawn photograph taken in winter and sent in spring, or the word false. He had asked the room a question about arithmetic, and the room, he could feel, was now asking it of itself, which was the only way rooms ever really decide anything.
The measure was not voted that night. There were procedural questions, raised by Renee with the air of a woman who has found a second locked door behind the first, about whether a covenant amendment of this kind required a two-thirds vote of the membership and a filing with the county, and the association's attorney, Furst, reached by telephone and put on speaker at the board table, allowed that it did, and that the packet had not said so, and that the vote would have to be noticed again and taken at a special meeting in the fall. Vivian thanked the attorney in a voice of perfect courtesy and closed the meeting twenty minutes later with the pond report, and if her hands were not entirely steady on the agenda, only the man standing beside her with the minutes was close enough to see it, and he had been watching her hands for nineteen years, and he wrote nothing down, and remembered everything.
The summer after the spring meeting was the strangest season of the Grants' two years on Ashford Trace, because it was, by every measure June kept, a good one.
The notices stopped. Not slowed; stopped. After April there were no cream envelopes, no sections cited, no conditions described. Elias logged the silence the way he logged everything, one line a month on the inside cover: May, nothing. June, nothing. A man trained in surveillance does not relax when a subject goes quiet. He notes the quiet, and he wonders what it is for, and he goes on mowing. But June was not trained in surveillance, and for June the summer was simply the summer: the pond, where the turtle of pizza dimensions was at last verified by three independent witnesses; the Nairs' pool on the weekends when the heat made the air visible; a lemonade stand, reconstituted under new management with a hand-lettered sign that read LEMONADE 50 CENTS NO REFUNDS, which did a brisk trade and was not reported to the county by anyone. In August she started third grade, in a classroom with a window that looked at a tree, with Mrs. Abernathy's successor as her teacher's aide, no relation, a coincidence of surnames that June found hilarious and reported at dinner with the gravity of a wire service.