Then the girl reached for the last nail, and the wind caught the banner full, and it bellied out like a sail, and the girl stepped back from the pull of it, and her shoe found the loose board again, and this time her foot went out from under her, and she stumbled, and her arms went wide, and she was falling toward the edge, toward the open air and the long drop to the yard below, and Mabel was on her feet before she knew she had moved, and she crossed the roof in three strides, and she caught the girl's arm as it flailed past her, and she caught it hard, and she pulled, and the girl's weight came against her, and Mabel set her feet wide on the warm boards, and she pulled again, and the girl came back from the edge, and they went down together onto the roof, hard, on their knees, and the hammer clattered away across the boards, and the banner flapped and tore at its nails, and then everything was still, and the only sound was the wind, and the girl's breathing, fast and ragged, and Mabel's own breathing, slower and deeper, and the smell of the herbs all around them.
Mabel did not let go of the girl's arm. She held it, and she felt the girl shaking, and she felt the thinness of the arm under the sleeve, and she thought about how young the girl was, for all her ordering and her arranging, and how frightened she must have been, up here on a roof with a banner and a hammer and a wedding coming in October, and she thought about her own hands, broad and brown from thirty years of work, and about the girl's hands, white and smooth, and about how the two pairs of hands had just done the same work, which was to hold on, and she said nothing, because there was nothing to say that would make it better, and because the girl was not ready for words, and because Mabel had learned that silence was sometimes the only honest thing a person could offer.
They sat on the roof together, in the silence, with the banner flapping above them and the valley spread out below, and the sun climbed higher, and the wind moved across the herbs, and the smell of sage and lavender rose around them, and the girl's breathing slowed, little by little, and her shaking eased, and she did not cry, and Mabel was glad of that, because tears would have made it harder, and because the girl had her pride, and because pride was a thing Mabel understood, and after a long while the girl turned her head, and she looked at Mabel, and her eyes were wide and dark, and she said, in a voice so low Mabel had to lean in to hear it, "Thank you," and Mabel nodded once, and she said, "Sit," and the girl sat, and they sat together a while longer, and the roof was warm under them, and the wind was cool on their faces, and neither of them spoke again.
Mabel thought about Agnes as they sat there, about the old woman downstairs in her kitchen with her keys in her pocket, sixty-eight years old and holding a house she had kept for forty years, and she thought about how Agnes had never once asked Mabel for thanks either, and how the two of them had kept the house together without ever making a speech about it, and she thought about Edwin, forty years old and rich and kind and blind in the way good men are blind, and about how he would need a house of his own one day, down below the hill, a house that was his and his wife's from the first nail, and not a house handed to him with another woman's life already living in every room, and she thought that the girl from Denver would have been happier in such a house, and that the trouble had never been the girl herself but the house she had been asked to fit herself into, and she thought about the nursery the girl had planned, and about the room that had been Agnes's for forty years, and about how a room could not be two things at once, and she thought all of this without bitterness, because bitterness would have done no good, and because the sun was warm, and because the girl beside her was alive, and because being alive was the whole of it, and the rest would settle itself in time.