shame rose up in her again, and she picked up her cup, and her hand was steady, and she drank, and the coffee was hot and strong, and she thought about the paper Edwin had signed, the paper that gave her this house as a wedding gift, and about how she had shown it to Agnes with a smile, and about how Agnes had looked at it and said nothing, and about how Agnes had locked her bedroom door that night and kept the key, and Vivian understood now that Agnes had never once raised her voice, and had never once pleaded, and had simply gone on keeping the house, day after day, the way she had kept it for forty years, and Vivian thought about the three hundred dollars' worth of goods she had ordered in Edwin's name, sitting in crates in the back room, and about the banner she had carried up the ladder herself, because she had wanted to show them all that she could manage a ranch house, and about how the ladder had slipped, and how the only thing between her and the ground had been Mabel's hand, and how Mabel had not said a word about it afterward, not to anyone, and had simply helped her down the ladder and gone back to the kitchen, and Vivian knew, with a certainty that settled in her like a stone in a riverbed, that if she had been the one holding the rope, she would have told everyone before supper, and the knowing of that difference was the thing that had kept her awake half the night, and the thing that had brought her downstairs in the gray dress, and she finished her coffee, and she set the cup down, and she looked at Agnes, and she looked at Mabel, and she said, "I need to speak to Edwin," and Agnes said, "He is in the corral with the hands," and Mabel said nothing at all, and Vivian stood up, and she went out the back door into the morning, and the sun was up over the hill, and the air smelled of cut hay and dust and coffee, and she walked down toward the corral, and her shoes kicked up little puffs of dust, and she thought about how she would say it plainly, because there was no other way to say it now.
Edwin was in the corral with two of the hands, working a young horse, and he had his sleeves rolled up, and his hat pushed back, and he looked up when he saw her coming, and he smiled, and the smile was the smile of a man who was glad to see his bride in the morning, and Vivian felt the smile like a weight, because she knew she was about to take it away, and she stopped at the fence, and she waited, and he came over to her, wiping his hands on his trousers, and he said, "Good morning, Vivian," and she said, "I need to speak to you, alone," and he told the hands to carry on, and he walked with her to the shade of the cottonwood by the creek, and she said, "Something happened yesterday, on the roof," and he said, "The banner," and she said, "Yes, the banner," and she told him, and she told it plainly, without dressing it up, and she told him how the ladder had slipped, and how she had been at the edge of the roof with nothing under her feet but air, and how Mabel had been up there drying the herbs, and how Mabel had reached out and taken hold of her wrist, and had pulled her back from the edge, and had held her until she could stand, and how the two of them had sat on the roof together afterward, with the herbs drying around them, and how Mabel had not said a word, and how Mabel had helped her down the ladder, rung by rung, and had gone back into the kitchen and started the supper, and how Mabel had told no one, and how she, Vivian, had not told anyone either, because she had been afraid, and because she had been ashamed, and because she had not known how to say that the woman she had tried to turn out of the house was the woman who had saved her life, and she told him all of it, and when she was done she stood there with her hands at her sides, and the creek ran past them, and the leaves moved, and Edwin did not speak for a long time, and when he did speak his voice