The morning had started the way most of my mornings start. The alarm at six-fifty. Coffee, black, at the kitchen counter while I planned the day. Peppers needed checking. The cucumbers needed tying up. Laura had a list for the grocery store, and I was supposed to meet her there at eight to help haul the heavy stuff, because she claimed I was better at judging melons than she was, which was flattery and we both knew it.
I'd loaded the truck with the things I needed to drop off in town — a bag of dead batteries for the recycling bin, the mower blade I meant to get sharpened — and backed out of the driveway a little after seven. The light was that clean early kind, the street still quiet, nobody's mower going yet. I turned east along the block, toward the main road, and that's when I saw her.
Marlene lived in the brick house on the other side of our eastern fence. She had lived there for four years and usually kept to herself. Polite wave at the mailbox, brief nod at the fence line, nothing more. In four years we'd barely exchanged more than a wave.
That morning she was standing beside the narrow gate leading into our garden.
Not walking past it. Standing beside it, close enough to touch it, turned half toward our yard like she'd been looking at something in there. She wore a gray jacket I didn't recognize, zipped up despite the mild morning, and her hair was pulled back tighter than usual.
I slowed the truck and lowered my window.
"Marlene?"
She turned quickly. Too quickly, I thought later. Like I'd startled her, though the truck wasn't exactly quiet.
"What are you doing back there?"
She smiled. It was a neat, practiced smile, the kind you give a stranger at a bus stop.
"Looking for my cat."
I frowned.
Marlene didn't own a cat.
Everyone on our street knew that. It wasn't gossip — it was just one of those settled facts, like the Hendersons' dog being afraid of thunder, or the fact that old Mr. Abernathy at number twelve was allergic to everything with fur and made sure the whole block knew it. Marlene had never owned a cat in the four years she'd lived there. She'd never mentioned wanting one. There had never been a cat.
But I was already late meeting Laura at the grocery store, and I had no time for a mystery.
So I had simply said, "There's no cat here."
She stepped back from the gate. The smile stayed where it was.
"My mistake."
Then I drove away.
I forgot about it by the second stoplight. What stayed with me later was how easily I'd let it go. A neighbor standing at my garden gate at twenty past seven in the morning, telling me a lie so clumsy a child would have been embarrassed by it, and I'd filed it under "not my problem" and driven on to buy melons.
We did the shopping. I judged the melons. We came home, and the day went on being ordinary. I worked in the garden. At four o'clock I sat down in my green chair with my coffee, the way I did every afternoon.
Now, six hours later, half a ton of water and steel had crashed onto the exact place where I usually sat.
I stood in the mud with my knees aching and looked at the gate. It was a narrow wooden gate in the eastern fence, the one the previous owners had put in for reasons I'd never figured out — it led nowhere except along the side of our house to the driveway. I'd oiled its hinges last spring. It swung silently. I'd always thought that was a nice touch, a well-kept gate. Now the thought of it swinging silently made my skin crawl.
Seven-twenty in the morning. The gray jacket. The smile that didn't move her eyes.
"Looking for my cat."
There was no cat. There had never been a cat. And even if there had been a cat — even if Marlene Bishop had secretly acquired a cat in the night and lost it by dawn — you don't stand at your neighbor's garden gate looking for it. You knock on the door. You call out. You do any of the dozen normal things people do, instead of standing there silent beside a gate that leads nowhere, at twenty past seven, in a zipped-up jacket.
Unless you weren't looking for a cat at all.
Unless you were looking at something else — at the tank, at the steel support, at the green folding chair sitting in the shade beneath it — and you'd needed a reason to be standing there in case someone drove past.
Someone had driven past.
Me.
I thought about her face when I'd lowered the window. The quick turn. The recovery. The story, ready a beat too fast, like she'd rehearsed it. "Looking for my cat." Four words, and every one of them wrong.
Laura was still watching me from the patio, Sophie beside her. The Labrador had finally stopped barking and lay down with his chin on his paws, staring at the wreckage.
"Daniel?" Laura said. "What is it?"
I kept looking at the gate. Then I looked past it, over the fence, at the brick house beyond — at Marlene's kitchen window, where a curtain hung very still in the morning light.
Except it wasn't morning anymore. It was late afternoon, and the light had gone amber, and somewhere in the back of my mind the arithmetic was starting again — colder this time, and pointed in a direction I didn't want to look.
"Nothing," I said. "I'll tell you in a minute."
But it wasn't nothing. It was 7:20, and a gray jacket, and a cat that didn't exist. And six hours later, half a ton of steel and water on the exact spot where I sat every afternoon at four o'clock.
* * *
I looked toward Marlene's house.
The brick house sat beyond our eastern fence, its kitchen window facing our garden across maybe thirty feet of yard and fence. A curtain hung in that window — pale, thin, the kind you can see movement through if you're watching.