It's mounted high on the back wall of the detached garage, tucked under the eaves, and it looks down the blind side of the garden — the strip between the garage and the fence that you can't see from the house, can't see from the patio, and can't see from Marlene's upstairs window. I put it there for the fertilizer thief. It turned out to be for something else entirely.
The timestamp read 07:19.
From this angle, the water tank filled the right side of the frame, huge and close, the steel curving away out of shot. And there, in the narrow gap between the tank and the garage wall, was Marlene.
This camera showed what the patio camera couldn't: her hands.
She was carrying something wrapped in a folded cloth. A tea towel, maybe, or a shop rag — gray, folded over twice, with something long and dark inside it. She held it against her side as she came around the back of the tank, the way you'd carry something you didn't want seen from the street.
"Stop," Perez said. "What's that?"
I paused the video. The bundle was visible for three frames, pressed between Marlene's coat and her hip.
"I don't know," I said honestly. "But I can guess."
Perez glanced at me. "Guess."
"A hacksaw. Or a reciprocating saw, a small one. Something that cuts steel."
Lewis wrote it down without looking up.
I pressed play. Marlene set the bundle down on the grass behind the tank — out of sight of the house, out of sight of the patio camera — and unfolded the cloth with quick, practiced movements. Whatever was inside caught the morning light for half a second. Long. Dark. A handle at one end.
She went to work on the support leg.
She didn't hack at it. She didn't attack it like someone in a film. She worked the way a person works when they know what they're doing — steady, rhythmic strokes, her body braced, pausing every few seconds to check her progress with her fingertips. The camera had no audio, but I could almost hear it: the thin, high singing of a saw biting into steel, seven o'clock in the morning, nobody awake to notice.
"She's done this before," Lewis said quietly. "Or she's watched someone do it."
"Ryan does bodywork," I said, before I could stop myself. "Cars. He's got a garage full of tools over at their place."
Perez looked at me sharply. "We'll get to that," she said, which was her way of telling me to stay in my lane.
On the screen, Marlene kept sawing. The timestamp moved with horrible slowness: 07:20. 07:21. Every so often she'd stop, wipe her forehead, and glance toward the house — just checking. Then back to work.
At 07:22 she stopped and ran her thumb along the cut, the way Perez had done that afternoon with the gash in the wreckage. Then she wrapped the tool back up in the cloth, tucked it under her coat, and stepped out from behind the tank.
And then she looked at my chair.
From camera three's angle, you could see her whole face. She stared at the chair for a long moment — and I mean stared, the way she'd stared in the patio footage, like she was doing sums in her head. Then she walked over to it, took hold of the backrest with both hands, and moved it.
Just a few inches. She dragged it sideways across the grass, stopped, stepped back, looked up at the tank, looked down at the chair, and moved it again — another few inches, nudging it with her foot this time, until it sat squarely in the worn patch of grass.
Directly beneath the tank's centerline.
I knew that patch of grass. Eleven years of afternoon sitting had worn it bare in exactly the shape of the chair's feet. She wasn't guessing where the chair went. She was putting it back where it always went — where I always sat — making sure it was precisely positioned under half a ton of steel and water.
"She moved the chair," Sophie said from the doorway, her voice thin.
"Yes," Perez said.
"Why would she move the chair?"
Nobody answered her. On the screen, Marlene stepped back one last time, surveyed the arrangement — the tank, the frame, the chair sitting dead center beneath it — and nodded. That same short, satisfied nod we'd seen on camera two.
Then she walked out of frame toward the gate, and the timestamp read 07:24, and the garden was empty again, and everything looked completely normal, except that one of the support legs was now cut three-quarters of the way through and my chair was sitting exactly where it needed to be for what came next.
Perez was very still. Then she said, "Play the last thirty seconds again."
So I did. The chair. The dragging. The nudging. The nod.
"She positioned it," Lewis said. "That's not — she didn't just move it. She positioned it."
"Under the centerline," I said. My voice sounded strange to me, flat and far away. "If the leg gives way, the tank tips toward the weakened side. The chair has to be exactly there, or it misses. She knew that."
"How would she know that?" Perez asked.
I thought about Ryan's garage full of tools. I thought about Marlene watching the camera installer from her upstairs window. I thought about eleven years of afternoons, visible to anyone who cared to look.
"Somebody taught her," I said. "Or somebody told her exactly what to do."
Perez nodded slowly, and wrote something down, and underlined it three times.
"Is there more footage?" she asked.
"There's the rest of the morning," I said. "The garden's empty until I come out at eight. But camera three —" I hesitated. "Camera three has audio. The others don't. I paid extra for audio on that one, because of the thefts."
Perez and Lewis looked at each other.
"Play it," Perez said. "From where she steps out from behind the tank."
I scrolled back to 07:22, and pressed play, and we all leaned in.
On the screen, Marlene tucked the wrapped tool under her coat. And then she took out her phone.