She made, over the following days, an inventory, because she was a teacher and inventory was her religion: two columns in her journal, *written* and *arrived*, built out of Bethan's drafts, out of neighbors' memories, out of her own. The results lay on the page with the clarity of a sum a child has got wrong on purpose. Petra Novak had written to Bethan four times in the autumn about the school subscription and received one answer, though Bethan's drafts showed three. The normal school had sent the new methods pamphlets Bethan begged for in October; they had never come. Nell herself had written on the second of January, and the sixteenth, and the thirtieth — full letters, newsy, ordinary, ending *write soon* — and Thomas, questioned gently, said that Bethan in January had twice wondered aloud why Nell had gone silent, and had cried over it once, a little, blaming her confinement and the weather. "She thought you'd tired of her," he said, and Nell had to leave the room and stand in the yard a moment among the sunflowers, holding her own elbows, while a rage she had no right to — a schoolmate's rage, nine years deep — went through her like weather through wheat.
The proof of it — for Nell had begun, in her journal, to use the word *proof* — arrived the following Monday in the hands of the mail rider, and it was addressed to Thomas in a hand from Ohio, and it had been mailed in March. It was a mother's letter to a widower: four months of condolence arriving in the heat of July, apologizing in its first paragraph for its own lateness, because Bethan's mother had written at once, in February, and again at Easter, and had received no answer, and had concluded at last that grief had made her son-in-law savage. Thomas stood in the kitchen doorway reading it with his lips moving, and Nell took the envelope from the table where he had laid it, and held it to the window light the way she held her pupils' slates to check a doubtful letter.
An envelope, opened by steam and patience, reseals politely. This one had been resealed in a hurry. Along the flap ran two tides of gum, the old one yellowed and grinning through, the new one laid over it in a ridge, with a thumbprint — she would swear to it in any company — smoothed into the join while it was wet. Nell said nothing. She laid the envelope back exactly as she had found it, and that evening she watched Willa build, unprompted, out of the afternoon's discards, a sentence Nell copied into her journal with a hand that was not entirely steady: LETTERS GET TIRED. LETTERS SLEEP AT THE DEPOT. — and under it, after a long pause to find the letters for it among the sack: MAMA WROTE. I SAW.
Petra Novak, consulted on her porch with her mending in her lap, snorted through her nose at the very suggestion that Bethan Greer had ever let a letter go unanswered in her life. "That woman answered a *catalog*, once, to correct the picture of a cabbage," said Petra. "I wrote her in the fall — the school money, the lumber my Josef promised. She answered me twice, she says in the second, *if my first has gone astray* — and I never had the first, Miss Hartigan, not to this day. I thought the creek took it. A letter does not swim." She drove her needle with unnecessary force. "Four times I write, one time she answers, and she the soul of answering. So. I keep her sampler in the parlor and I think: somebody in this county reads other people's answers and keeps them, like eggs from another man's hens."
The letters of the Greer household had not been lost the way letters are lost, singly, by weather and distance and honest mishap. They had been *culled* — the way you cull a flock — and culled by someone with a taste for particular subjects: the school, the spring, the normal school, anyone who might have advised Bethan Greer, in writing, that she was right to refuse.
And all mail for Willow Ford passed, by contract, through one pair of hands.
The depot at Willow Ford was a long low building that smelled of coal smoke, machine oil, and the peculiar sweet rot of mail sacks left in heat. Nell went in on the Saturday with a letter of her own to post — to the registrar, requesting, in terms of studied innocence, a list of all communications received from Mrs. Thomas Greer between October and February — and she watched young Sam Whitfield take it from her across the counter.
Sam was sixteen, all wrists and Adam's apple, the stationmaster's hired boy, and Nell had spoken to him perhaps five times: about the train times, about a parcel of slates, about the heat. He had a pleasant, open, freckled face, the face of a boy who has been well raised and is proud of being trusted with keys. But when she said, "This one matters to me, Sam. I want to be sure it goes out on the noon train," the boy's eyes went — not to the letter, not to her — but sideways, up and to the left, toward the door of the little locked room behind the counter where the mail sacks waited for Amos Keller's contractor's cart, and his hand, taking her letter, fumbled it once against the counter's edge.