"Show me the paper," Anker said.
Dugan smiled, a thin smile that did not reach his eyes, and reached into his coat. He drew out a folded paper, creased and softened from carrying, and held it out. Anker took it, unfolded it carefully, and read it, slowly, because a paper read in haste was a paper misread, and this paper would decide what happened next. The storekeeper came forward then, because reading papers was part of his trade, and he read it over Anker's shoulder, his lips moving silently, and then he looked up at Dugan with an expression Anker could not quite read, something between caution and doubt.
The paper was not what Dugan had said it was. It was a filing, yes, and it bore a date three years back, but it did not name this wash or this spring. It named a creek two valleys to the east, a place Anker had never seen and Dugan's outfit had never watered stock at, so far as anyone in Red Wash knew. And it was not a water filing at all. It was a grazing permit, a paper that allowed an outfit to run cattle on open ground for a season, and it had no seal, no survey, and no surveyor's mark, only a clerk's hurried signature at the bottom, the kind of signature that got put on a hundred papers in a busy week at a county office. Anker read it twice, to be sure, and then he folded it again, neatly, and held it out to Dugan.
"This paper," Anker said, his voice steady and plain, "names a creek two valleys east of here. It is a grazing paper, not a water paper. It has no seal and no survey. It does not name this well, or this spring, or this wash. It gives your outfit nothing here.
The storekeeper cleared his throat then, because reading a paper aloud was part of his trade, and he read the key lines in a steady voice so that everyone standing by could hear them: the creek named, the grazing season, the clerk's signature, and the absence, which he noted plainly, of any seal or surveyor's mark. The council's eldest, who had settled disputes in Red Wash for longer than Anker had been in the territory, asked Dugan a simple question then: when had his outfit last watered stock at this wash, or at any water within a day's ride of it? Dugan did not answer directly. He spoke instead of filings and of rights and of the way things were done up north, where an outfit's word carried further than a clerk's seal, and Anker listened to the evasion and understood it for what it was. A man with a true claim answers the question about the water. A man with a paper about another creek talks about everything except the water."
Dugan's face darkened, and the thin smile went out of it like a lamp going out in a wind. He took the paper back, folded it roughly, and shoved it into his coat. His three riders shifted in their saddles, and one of them let his hand rest on the butt of his revolver, not drawing it, but letting it be seen, the way a man lets a thing be seen when he wants it to do his talking for him. Anker saw it, and he did not move toward his own belt, because he had no gun on him at the well, and because reaching for a weapon at a well in the morning was how mornings turned into funerals, and funerals did not fill troughs.
"You think a paper is the whole of it," Dugan said, his voice lower now, and harder. "Papers are for towns with clerks. Out here, water belongs to whoever can hold it. My outfit has men, and money, and wagons, and we will not watch a town and a band of wanderers fence off a spring we filed on while our cattle go thirsty up north."
"We have not fenced anything," Anker said. "The well stands open by a schedule, mornings for the town, afternoons for the Cobre people, Sundays shared. Anyone who comes in their turn draws. That is the agreement, and it is written, and it is witnessed from both sides."
Dugan laughed, a short, hard sound. "An agreement," he said, "between a town and a band with no standing anywhere. Written by a storekeeper. Witnessed by nobodies. You think that holds against an outfit? I will bring a crew, and a fence line, and we will see how long your paper lasts when there are men on it."