Luz let out a breath she had been holding since before dawn. Anker looked at her, and this time he did smile, a small, tired smile, the smile of a man who had dug a well and then watched a whole crowd learn how to keep it.
"Well," he said. "That is done."
"It is done for today," Luz said. "Dugan will remember, as he said. But so will we. And we have the paper, and we have each other, and we have the water. That is more than he has."
The townsfolk began to draw water then, in the Sunday order the agreement laid down: first the town families, then the Cobre families, sharing the rope and the bucket, helping each other lift the jars, the children splashing in the ditch water where it ran clear toward the gardens. Luz drew her family's share last, as she always did, and when she lifted the jar to her shoulder, the water was cold and clean, and it smelled of deep earth and stone, the way true water always does.
She stood for a moment at the well curb, looking out over the valley where the town and the camp both lay under the same sun, and she thought about what her mother had told her, long ago, about hands being a woman's first argument and her last one. Her hands had helped dig this well. Her hands had written nothing on the agreement — Anker had written it — but her hands had found the water, and her hands had carried the jar, and her hands, today, had stood beside sixty other pairs of hands around a well and said, without a word, that the water belonged to everyone who kept it.
That, she thought, was an argument no bully could answer, because it was not made of words at all. It was made of people, standing together, doing an ordinary thing, on an ordinary morning, under a paper they had all agreed to keep.
The sun was fully up now, and the valley was bright, and the water ran clear in the ditch, and Luz turned toward home with the jar on her shoulder, thinking already about the next thing that would need doing, which was the thing she had been thinking about all along: a second well, at the Cobre camp itself, so that her people would not have to walk an hour each way for every jar, and so that the agreement would have two wells to stand on instead of one.
Her cousin fell into step beside her on the trail home, carrying his own jar, and for a while they walked in silence, the way people walk after something important has happened and the words for it have not yet settled. Then he said, "Do you think he will come back?"
"Dugan?" Luz asked.
"He said outfits remember."
"Outfits remember," Luz agreed, "but so do towns, and so do camps. And a man who has once stood before sixty people and found no paper in his hand strong enough to stand beside theirs will think twice before he stands there again. He may come back with lawyers. He may come back with talk. But he will not come back with a claim he can read aloud, because he does not have one, and today everyone saw that he does not have one."
By the time they reached the camp, the sun was high and the children were already at the water jars, and Luz set her own jar down in the shade of her family's shelter and stood for a moment with her hands on her hips, looking out toward the ground where the second well would go. It was not much to look at yet: dry grass, red dirt, a slope of stone. But she had learned, over a summer of digging with a Norwegian who listened to the ground the way other men listened to music, that the ground told its secrets to people who were patient enough to ask twice. She would ask Anker to come and look at that ground with her, not as a hired man this time, but as a partner. She would ask him tomorrow, and whatever he answered, the first well would still stand, the agreement would still hold, and the water would still run clear in the ditch on Sunday mornings, shared by all.