Meanwhile the town's own water was failing faster than anyone had admitted. The seep a mile down the arroyo, which had been a dark stain in the morning, shrank to a damp patch that a woman could cover with her hand, and the water the women carried back in their buckets was brown and gritty and had to be left standing to settle before it could be drunk. One morning the bucket from the town's better well came up with nothing but mud and a drowned beetle, and the storekeeper, who had kept a cheerful face through the whole summer, went quiet for the rest of the day. People began to talk, in the low voices people use when they are frightened and do not want to frighten each other further, about how long the seep would last, and about whether the wagons could be loaded if it came to leaving, and about which road would be passable with children and old people in the heat.
Anker heard the talk, because a small town has no corners quiet enough to hide talk in, and he carried it with him to the shaft each morning like one more tool he had not asked for. He did what he could with what he had. He gave his own drinking water to the children who had brought him the cup on the first day, when he found them sitting in the shade of the store with cracked lips, and he did it without making a show of it, because a gift made into a show was not a gift at all. He ate less at supper so that there would be more for others, though no one asked him to, and he slept in the stable loft with his door open to the night air, listening to the town breathe and to his mule shifting below, and wondering whether he had misread the ground from the very first day.
That was the hardest part of a dry shaft, harder than the digging and harder than the doubt of others: the doubt of oneself. In the evenings, when the work was done, Anker sat on the edge of the dry hole with his legs hanging down into it and went over his reading again, the way a man goes over a letter he has already read a dozen times, looking for the sentence he missed. The clay had been there. He had felt it in the auger, dark and true. The dip had been there. He had traced it with borings across the hollow. The willows had been there, their roots reaching down toward something. And yet the gravel below the clay was dry, and the hardpan below the gravel was dry, and the auger had found nothing but dust all the way down. Somewhere in his chain of reasoning there was a link that did not hold, and he could not find it by staring at the hole. He could only find it by boring wider, and by admitting, first to himself and then to the town, that the hollow had told him only half the truth.
He remembered, in those evenings, the dry hole of his youth, the one he had mentioned to no one in Red Wash except in the most general terms. He had been twenty-three then, and sure of himself in the way that young men are sure of things they have not yet failed at, and he had dug forty feet through dust in another dry valley because he had been certain the water was there. It had not been there. The town had paid him nothing, as agreed, and he had walked out of that valley with nothing but his tools and a lesson that had never left him: that certainty was the most expensive thing a digger could own, and that the ground repaid certainty with dust. He had been more careful ever since, and yet here he was, in Red Wash, with a dry shaft behind him and a town running out of water in front of him, and the lesson felt as fresh as if he had learned it yesterday.