"Then be reasonable about this," Anker said, and his voice was as quiet as it had been three days before, but there was something underneath it now, a steadiness that came from standing with a crowd at his back instead of alone. "Lay your paper beside ours. Let them be read together, in front of everyone here. If your claim is older and stronger, the witnesses will say so, and we will abide by it."
Dugan's smile did not change, but his eyes did. They moved, quickly, from Anker's face to the agreement, to the witnesses, to the crowd, and Luz saw in that movement the whole shape of his problem. He had no paper. Or if he had a paper, it was not the kind that could be laid beside another paper and read aloud in front of sixty people without falling apart. His claim had always depended on being made in private, to one man at a time, in a voice that left no room for questions. It had never been made to stand up in a crowd, in daylight, next to a document with four witnesses' marks on it.
"I do not need to lay anything beside anything," Dugan said, and his voice was a shade less smooth than it had been. "I am telling you how it is. This outfit does not ask permission to water its cattle."
"And this town does not ask permission to drink," said the storekeeper, stepping forward from the townsfolk, his voice rough but steady. "We hired this man to dig. We paid him. The Cobre people helped find the water. The agreement is written and witnessed. That is how it is, too."
A murmur went through the crowd then, not loud, not angry, but deep, the sound of many people agreeing at once, and Luz felt something in her chest loosen that she had not known was tight. It was one thing to believe a crowd would stand. It was another thing to hear it stand, in its own voice, without being told to.
Dugan looked around him slowly, and Luz watched him count, the way she had watched him count before. He counted the townsfolk. He counted the Cobre people. He counted his own three riders, and he counted the distance to his horse, and he counted the hours it would take to ride back to his outfit and return with more men, and he counted what those men would find when they got here: not a lone well-digger, not a frightened town, but a written agreement and a crowd that had already stood once and would stand again.
He was a bully, Luz thought, but he was not a fool, and bullies who are not fools know the difference between a fight they can win by talking and a fight that will cost them more than the prize is worth. The well was worth a great deal. But a war with a whole town and a whole camp, over a well with a written agreement and witnesses on both sides, was worth more trouble than any cattle buyer needed, especially when the same water could be had by asking for a share like everyone else.
"I see how it is," Dugan said at last, and his voice had changed again, back to smooth, but thinner now, the smoothness of a man covering a retreat. "I see that you have made your arrangements. I will not stand here and argue with a crowd on a Sunday morning. But understand me, Vollan: outfits remember. Claims do not go away because a crowd stands around a well."
"Claims do not go away," Anker agreed, "but neither do agreements. And this agreement is written, witnessed, and kept by both sides, week by week. If your outfit wants water, it can ask for a share like everyone else, and the share will be measured the same as any other."
Dugan looked at Anker for a long moment, and then at Luz, and then at the agreement on the board, and then he turned, walked back to his horse, mounted without hurry, and rode away up the north road with his three riders behind him. He did not look back. The dust settled behind them, and the crowd stood quiet for a moment longer, as if making sure the quiet was real, and then the ordinary sounds of a Sunday morning came back: a child asking for a drink, a jar clinking against the curb, a woman laughing somewhere at the edge of the crowd.