man's word, Yano said, offered to acquit the band by condemning a white
colonel — and did no one else at this fire hear how convenient that music
was? If the committee believed Decker, the band would owe its valley to a
white man's mercy, and be grateful, and be quiet. If the committee did not
believe him, the band would have spent its one hearing holding up a traitor as
a truth-teller, and the paper men would write them down discredited and be
done. Either way the valley would hang on a white man's memory — the
memory of the man whose report had located the camp. Yano said he did not
call Decker a liar. He said a man might believe his own story after twelve
years of telling it to himself in the dark; grief and shame were water, and
water wore a channel in stone. But he asked the council why the band should
stake its home — its graves, its spring, its unborn — on the channel worn in
that particular stone.
He sat down to a silence that gave his words their full weight. Amos,
listening, could not hate the young man for any of it. Yano was not a villain
and did not speak like one; he spoke like a son standing over a grave with the
59
only weapon grief had left him — suspicion, honestly held.
Kito let the silence stand until it had finished its work. Then he spoke,
briefly, in the manner of a man who has counted a cost before and recognizes
the arithmetic.
"My father counted this cost already," Kito said, through Sela's quiet voice.
"On the night of the fire, Nahlin was offered two roads by the dark. He could
keep the band together and fight the soldiers in the valley, among the lodges,
where the children were. Or he could spend eleven men at the crossing —
eleven, whose names Tasun keeps — to buy the silence and the darkness for
the rest to climb. He chose the fire and the eleven, knowing exactly what it
cost, because counting costs was his work, the way keeping the words is
Tasun's work and riding is yours, Yano. Now the paper men offer us two
roads again. We can stake the valley on rifles, here, at this mesa, and lose it
in a season, with other names for Tasun to keep. Or we can stake it on the
whole truth — our record and theirs, the fire seen from both sides of it —
and give the truth one chance to do what rifles cannot. My father, when he
had to choose, chose the road that spent the fewest of his people. I am his
son. I choose as he chose." He looked around the fire, face by face. "The
band will go to the hearing. The scout will ride with us — not in front, not
behind. With us. Let any man who cannot walk that road say so now, while
the fire is lit."
No one spoke. Yano looked into the fire a long time, and Amos watched the
young man's jaw work once, and settle, the way a gate settles into a latch. He
did not rise, and he did not leave, and in the arithmetic of the council those
two facts together were themselves a kind of assent — not agreement, but
allegiance, which the Apache held to be the stronger coin.
Then it was Sela's turn, and she did a thing that silenced even the children at
60
the fire's edge. She took the copy packet from Amos's saddlebag wrap — he
gave it to her with both hands — and she opened it on the blanket before the
fire, and she read the white men's record aloud to the council, first in English,
cleanly, the mission girl's schooling standing straight in her voice, and then
again in the band's own tongue, rendering Lark's statement and the priest's
attestation and the colonel's short letter into the language of the people it had
been done to. Amos listened to his own vindication travel into Apache, and it
sounded in that tongue less like a defense than like weather described — a
thing that had happened, in a place, to people, with names.
When she came to the letter, she read the operative words last and let them
lie in the firelight: the instruction in Whitlock's own hand, to take the
command to the place in the scout's report and let providence settle the
parley.
An old woman across the fire made a sound, low, not quite a word. Kito's
face did not change, but his eyes stayed on Amos a moment, weighing the
man against the paper, finding, perhaps, that for the first time in twelve years
the two agreed.
"The priest kept this a year," Kito said at last. "The dead man kept it longer.
Paper is patient. Men are not always." He nodded once, slow. "Now let the
band's record be spoken. Tasun. The words of Nahlin, as they were given to
you, as you have kept them. All of them. So the scout hears his own night
from the other side of the fire, and the two records stand up together here
before ever they stand in the capital."
Tasun rose.
He was not the oldest man at the fire — the story-keeper, the one into whose
memory the band poured its history. He had kept Nahlin's account for twelve
61
years, word by word as the dying chief had dictated it in the rocks above the