to be called a liar in the proper form.
The committee heard Colonel Whitlock first, on his own motion, and he rose
the way he had always risen from a camp table when the maps came out —
unhurried, certain of the ground because he had drawn it. He did not argue. A
man does not argue with a room he has already furnished, and Whitlock had
furnished this one out of his own book. He spoke of 1869 as a closed
account: audited, printed, bound. In the autumn of that year, he said, the
department, anxious for peace, had sent its scout — a young man of promise,
fluent in the tongue — to treat with Nahlin at White Mesa. The scout's
report, honestly rendered, had disclosed what the department most feared: the
camp's rifles cleaned and cached, its horses gathered and grained, its young
men counting themselves for war — a raid in preparation against the river
settlements, timed for the first cold. He let a pause do the work of evidence.
"I acted upon intelligence, gentlemen. A commander who waits for certainty
buries settlers."
The dawn attack he described as a surgeon describes an amputation: severe,
necessary, and somebody else's fault for being required. The casualties had
fallen among those who resisted. The remnant had withdrawn to the rocks.
Twelve years of an imperfect peace had followed, and the territory had
88
grown up around the question this bill now merely answered: whether a
copper valley should lie idle under a few dozen lodges because a retired
officer's conscience had grown tender in print. He did not raise his voice at
any point. He did not need to. Print had raised it for him years ago.
Only at the end did he turn, courteous as a headsman, toward the witnesses'
row. The committee would hear, he said, from the scout himself — or from
what twelve years of solitude had left of him. A hermit dug out of a canyon,
half crazed by guilt and weather, reciting a romance the band had taught him.
"A broken man the band has dressed up as a witness," he said, with the regret
of a man reading a casualty list, "when he is not their prisoner outright —
brought down out of his rocks to recant, in his ruin, the one honest report he
ever made when he was whole." He sat. The newspapermen wrote.
Somewhere a stove ticked as it warmed.
Amos looked at his own hands and thought of the morning, a week past,
when he had walked out of his cabin into a ring of leveled rifles with his
hands open, expecting the past to finish its arithmetic at last — and the past
had instead handed him back his life with instructions. Prisoner. He turned
the word over once and let it go. Paper could hold anything laid on it; that
was its strength, and Amos had twelve years' practice at knowing it was also
its weakness. Whitlock had not come to this room to argue. He had come to
watch his book be read into the record of its own vindication, and he sat now
with the mild patience of a man who believes — because in his world it had
always been true — that what is printed outranks what is remembered.
They called Amos Decker after the noon of the morning had gone, and he
came forward out of the witnesses' row with his saddlebag in his hand,
because what he had to show the committee was in it and he did not intend to
be separated from it. The clerk swore him on a Bible worn soft as cloth. He
89
gave his name, his age, his service: scout and interpreter in the employ of the
department in the year 1869, and no employer since worth the naming. The
chairman invited him to give the committee his account of the autumn of that
year, in his own order, without interruption. Amos set the saddlebag on the
witness table, and began where a man must begin who does not intend to be
caught beginning anywhere else.
"I carried the location out of that camp in my report because I believed a
colonel's promise," he said. "Put that in your record before anything else I
say."
He told it in order, the way he had told it to no one, the way a scout reports
country: no weather in it that did not matter. The ride in under Nahlin's own
safe-conduct. Two days of talk in the camp at White Mesa — a hunting
camp, families, forty lodges if it was forty, old men and children and dogs,
and rifles enough to hunt with and not enough to make the war the red book
described. Nahlin wanting the valley kept and the peace kept with it: the
band would hold its young men off the river road, would move its herds from
the settlers' grass, would treat with any commission the government sent in
honesty. The oath on the second evening. Here Amos opened the saddlebag
and took out two white river stones, each the size of a man's palm, smooth as
eggs, and set them on the witness table in front of the committee, one and
then the other, with the unhurried care of a man setting out the only furniture
he owns. The room made its first true silence of the day.
"They were set between us on the blanket," Amos said. "One stone for the