Felipe glanced up. "Dust is always red out here."
"Not like that day. That day it hung in the air. It got in my teeth." Goyah shifted his crutches. "The stage was coming around the bend below Cinder Hill. I was riding point, maybe fifty yards ahead. I heard the first shot from the rocks on the left."
"I heard it from the right," Felipe said.
They looked at each other then, really looked, for the first time since the yard.
"I was on the left flank," Felipe said slowly. "Wren's patrol. Four of us. The shots came from both sides at once — I remember thinking that, thinking it was wrong, an ambush doesn't split its fire like that. I went down — " he touched his shoulder. "I saw you go down. I thought — " He stopped.
"You thought I shot you," Goyah said.
"I thought you shot me," Felipe admitted. "You were the only gun I could see."
"I never raised my rifle," Goyah said. "It was across my back the whole time. I was reaching for it when the second shot took me in the side." He looked down at his hands. "I thought you shot me. You were the only rider I could see."
The hawk screamed once, far above.
"There was a man in the rocks," Felipe said. "Above the bend. I saw him when I fell — my head was turned that way. Red bandana over his face. He was working a lever rifle like he was getting paid by the shot."
Goyah went very still. "Red bandana."
"You saw him too."
"I saw him." Goyah's voice had changed. "I thought he was one of yours."
Felipe shook his head slowly. "Nobody on Wren's patrol wears red. Wren docks a day's pay for what he calls vanity. Gray scarves or nothing — his rule." He leaned forward, wincing as his shoulder protested. "And your people?"
"My people do not wear red into a fight," Goyah said. "Red is for weddings."
Walt set down the oil can. He went inside without a word, and the two men watched the doorway, the easy quiet between them suddenly fragile, as if it might tear like wet paper. He came back with something small cupped in his palm, and he set it on the porch table exactly halfway between them.
Two brass cartridge cases, dull with dust, dented at the lips.
"I went back to where you fell," Walt said. "Two days after you crawled to my fence. I told myself I was looking for anything the patrol missed. Truth is I wanted to understand what kind of men I'd taken in." He nudged the cases with one finger. "Same mold. Same batch. Whoever shot you both loaded from the same box."
Felipe picked one up and turned it over in his fingers. Goyah took the other. They sat there, a wounded Apache scout and a wounded Mexican vaquero, each holding half of the same answer, and the silence stretched long enough for a bee to land on the table, walk a deliberate circuit around the brass, and depart.
"Then who shot us?" Felipe asked quietly.
Goyah looked at the mountains for a long time. When he spoke, his voice was low and certain, the way a man sounds when a thing he has carried for weeks finally sets itself down.
"The man who needed us to shoot each other."
---
That night Walt sat at his table long after the lamp burned low, mending a harness strap by feel more than sight. The house was quiet in the way it had been quiet for five years — but it was a different quiet now, he realized. It had weight. It had breathing in it.
Through the thin wall of the spare room he heard Felipe's voice, soft, whistling — a slow Mexican waltz, the kind of tune a man whistles when he thinks no one is listening. Walt's hands stilled on the leather.
A pause. Then, from the barn side, faint through two walls and the yard between: tap. Tap-tap. Tap.
Goyah, keeping time with the end of his crutch against the barn floor.
The whistling went on, a little stronger now. The tapping settled into the rhythm like a second instrument joining a song, and Walt thought of the dances in town in the old days, before the fever year, when Ruth would pull him onto the floor and he would protest and then surrender, and the whole room would smell of dust and fiddle rosin.
Walt sat in the dark and smiled, and he did not feel foolish about it at all. Somewhere in the rafters a bee that had wandered in for the night droned once, drowsy and content, and Walt thought of Ruth — not the burying, not the fever, just Ruth humming at the stove while the rain hit the roof.