Walt listened to both tellings — one in fever-murmur, one in laudanum-slur — and said nothing to either of them. He just kept bringing the soup.
He served it the way he'd separated everything else: at opposite ends of the world. Goyah got his bowl on the porch outside the spare bedroom, in the thin shade of the house wall, where he could sit propped against the doorframe and eat without seeing the barn. Felipe got his on an upturned crate at the barn door, where he could watch the hives and the road and not see the house. Walt carried the bowls back and forth like a ferryman, and neither man ever saw the other eat.
On the fourth evening, Goyah was sitting up against the doorframe working his way through a bowl of cornmeal mush when Walt sat down on the porch steps with his own bowl and said, "You want to know what I did before bees?"
Goyah didn't answer. He rarely did. But he didn't look away, which Walt had learned was his version of listening.
"I cooked for mule trains," Walt said. "Twenty years. Forty, fifty men, twice a day, in weather that would kill a lizard. You learn things, feeding men. You learn that a man will tell you the truth about his mother and lie to you about his debts, and both in the same sentence." He ate a spoonful of mush. "You learn that the man stirring the pot sees everything and nobody notices him seeing it."
Goyah ate. The hives hummed.
"My wife," Walt said, "her name was Ruth. She could make bread rise in a cold kitchen, which is a miracle I never understood and stopped questioning after the first year. Five years ago she caught the fever. Three days. That's all it took — three days, and I was digging a hole under the mesquite out back." He pointed with his spoon toward the dark shape of the tree beyond the hives. "I put her down there, and the bees came. Whole cloud of them. Settled right on the coffin lid while I was shoveling. Like they were standing watch."
He didn't say it sadly. That was the thing about Walt — he told the truth the way other men reported the weather. It had happened. It was real. It sat in him like a stone sits in a field: permanent, not discussed.
"Five years," he said. "You get used to the quiet. Then you stop noticing it's quiet. Then two boys show up bleeding on your fence and you remember what noise sounds like." He stood, collecting Goyah's empty bowl. "Eat tomorrow too. Doctor's orders."
In the barn, Felipe was feeding crumbs of his cornbread to a barn cat that had adopted him without permission. Walt sat on a hay bale with his bowl.
"Your family," Walt said. "They near?"
Felipe's hand stilled on the cat's head. "My father is in Perdido. My mother — she was sick. That's why — " He stopped. "That's my business."
"Fair," Walt said. "Everybody's got business." He ate. "My wife died five years back. Fever. I buried her under the mesquite out past the hives. Bees sat on the coffin like mourners."
Felipe looked at him then, really looked, and something shifted in his face — the particular softening of a young man hearing an older man's grief and recognizing the shape of it.
"I'm sorry," Felipe said, and it sounded like he meant it.
"Me too," Walt said. "Every day. Then I go check the hives, and the day goes anyway." He stood. "Rest that shoulder. The doctor says you're healing crooked out of pure stubbornness."
Dr. Ada Bloom came back on the sixth day, and she brought her sharp eyes and her sharper tongue and a fresh roll of bandages. She went through both patients methodically — unwrapped, probed, sniffed, re-wrapped — and then she stood on Walt's porch with her hands on her hips and said, "Walt. Come look at this."
She had laid two things on the porch rail: the slug she'd dug out of the barn wall where it had lodged after passing through Felipe's shoulder, and a twisted piece of lead she'd extracted from Goyah's flank dressing.
"Same caliber," she said. "Forty-four. And look at the rifling marks." She turned the slugs so the light caught the grooves. "Same twist. Same wear pattern. Walt, these two weren't shot by each other. They were shot by the same rifle — or rifles from the same batch, same gunsmith. And the angles — " She touched her own side, then her shoulder. "Both shot from above and to the right. Same position. Same shooter, or shooters standing shoulder to shoulder."
Walt looked at the two slugs for a long time.
"You're sure," he said.
"I'm a doctor, not a gunsmith, but I've dug enough lead out of enough men to know when two wounds match." She wrapped the slugs in a cloth and handed them to him. "Whoever robbed that stage shot them both and left them. And each of them woke up believing the other one did it."