A murmur ran through the crowd. Wren's smile didn't move, but something behind it went very still.
"Of course," Wren said smoothly. "I have nothing to hide. Though I must say, this is highly irregular—"
"So is robbery, Mr. Wren." Fry gestured to the vault door. "Open it."
---
The night before, the assay office had been dark except for one lantern moving behind the barred windows.
Les Dugan had never been a patient man, and patience was what the night required. He'd waited until past midnight, until the last light in the Mercantile went out, and then he'd gone in through the back with two of Wren's men and started loading the money bags — the payroll, and the rest of it, the skim and the fines and the debts bought and sold — into canvas sacks for the run to the border.
He was halfway through when the lantern light found him.
Sheriff Tom Bannister stepped out of the shadows of the assay yard with a shotgun held easy across his forearms, and behind him came Fry's two federal deputies with rifles, and Dugan understood, in the space of one heartbeat, that the trap had been set around him while he was busy setting traps for other people.
"Les Dugan," Bannister said, and his voice didn't shake, not once. "You're under arrest for theft, conspiracy, and about eleven other things Mr. Fry wrote down for me. Put the sacks down."
Dugan looked at the shotgun, at the rifles, at the federal badges catching the lantern light. He was a bounty hunter by trade; he knew arithmetic when he saw it.
"Boss'll have your house for this, Tom," he said.
"My house," Bannister said quietly, "is already his. That's the trouble with being owned. You stop being afraid of losing things." He nodded at the deputies. "Take him."
They took Dugan to the county lockup, and somewhere around two in the morning, with the federal warrant on the table in front of him and twenty years in Yuma on the other side of it, Les Dugan did what cornered men have always done. He started talking. Names, dates, routes, the red bandanas, the payroll split, the fines that were never filed. He talked until dawn grayed the cell window, and one of Fry's deputies wrote it all down in a hand almost as neat as Duffy Malone's.
"Boss'll kill me," Dugan said at one point, staring at his own hands.
Bannister, who'd sat through the whole of it with his shotgun across his knees, said, "Boss is finished, Les. The only question left is whether you go down with him or walk out the other side."
Dugan talked for another hour after that.
By the time the sun came up, the prosecution had its witness — and Tom Bannister had arrested a man in the middle of the night without flinching, and stood a little taller for it, and would stand a little taller for the rest of his life.
---
The vault door swung open on oiled hinges, and the crowd pressed forward, and Fry's deputies kept them back with the flat authority of men who'd done it before.
Inside, on a shelf in the lamplight, sat the stage company's strongbox — iron-banded oak, the brass seal of the line unbroken across the hasp.
A sound went through the plaza like wind through wheat.
Fry stepped forward and examined the seal without touching it, the way a man might examine a wound. He nodded to one of his deputies, who lifted the box out with both hands and set it on the assay office counter for all to see. The seal caught the morning light — intact, official, damning in its very perfection. Whatever Wren had intended to claim about this box, the seal told its own story: it had never been opened by honest hands since the robbery.
Wren recovered first. "There," he said, spreading his hands, magnanimous. "As I told Mr. Fry in private — my men recovered that box after the robbery, at considerable risk. I intended to turn it over to the company at the earliest—"
"Six thousand dollars," Fry said. He wasn't looking at Wren. He was looking at the strongbox. "That's the figure you reported recovered, Mr. Wren. In your letter to the company dated Monday."
"Approximately—"
"The payroll was eight thousand." Fry opened the daybook — Duffy Malone's daybook, the duplicate, the one Wren had believed no one could read — and held it up so the crowd could see the page. "Eight thousand dollars dispatched. Six thousand reported recovered. Two thousand dollars —" he turned the page with deliberate care, "— entered here, in this hand, as 'retained.' Your hand, Mr. Wren. Or shall we have Mr. Malone confirm it? He's waiting at the church, I believe, sober for the first time in a year and eager to testify."
Wren's face had gone the color of old paper. "That book is stolen property. The ravings of a drunk—"