The Garden She Plowed Under on Aspen Creek Lane

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The next morning I wrote the letter I had been composing in my head all night, sitting at the same table with a pen that kept running dry and a second pen that worked better. I kept it plain and polite, because I wanted no one to be able to say I had been rude or vague. I asked for the adoption record for the rule banning unmanaged native plantings, the rule dated 14 April: the meeting notice, the agenda, the minutes showing the vote, the names of the board members present, and any written notice sent to homeowners before the rule took effect. I asked for a copy, not a summary, and I asked for it in writing. I signed my full name, Eleanor Grant, and I wrote our address, 9 Aspen Creek Lane, at the top, and I made two copies, one for the board and one for my folder. Tom drove me to the small HOA office near the entrance to Blue Spruce Estates, a low building with a locked drop box and a sign that said office hours were limited, and I slid the letter through the slot and heard it land with a soft thud. I stood there for a moment with my hand still on the box, feeling oddly formal, as if I had just posted something that mattered more than a bill. On the drive home Tom said, "If they have the record, they will show it, and then we will know where we stand." I nodded, but I was already thinking about what it would mean if they did not show it, and I did not like either answer very much.

The answer, when it came, was not an answer at all. Harold Crane called three days later, and his voice was careful in the way of a man reading from notes he did not want to be quoted on. "Mrs. Grant, the board received your request," he said. "The records are under review. There are procedures for this sort of thing. We cannot simply hand over internal board papers on demand." I asked what procedure, and how long a review would take, and his carefulness only deepened. "The board will respond in due course," he said. "You should focus on bringing the property into compliance in the meantime. The fines continue to accrue under the rule as written." I wrote down his words as he spoke, the pen scratching across my notepad, because I had learned by then that memory was not enough and that a conversation could be reshaped later if no one had written it down. When I asked if I could see the agenda for the 14 April meeting, Harold said agendas were filed with the minutes and were also under review. When I asked who had voted, he said the vote was recorded in the minutes, which were under review. It was a circle with no door in it, and by the end of the call I felt the same frustration I had felt on the porch with Diane, only quieter, because this time no one had raised their voice at all.

I went to the next board meeting anyway, because a letter in a drop box is easy to set aside and a person in a chair is harder to ignore. The meeting was held in the community room with folding chairs in rows and a long table at the front, and Diane sat in the middle with Harold on one side and Linda Marsh on the other, a stack of papers in front of each of them. The room smelled faintly of coffee and floor cleaner, and the fluorescent lights made everything look a little too bright. When the floor opened for homeowner comments I stood up, and my knees shook in a way they had not when I was younger and standing in front of a room, but my voice held. I said I had requested the adoption record for the 14 April rule and had not received it, and I asked the board to provide the notice, the agenda, and the minutes, or to say plainly if they could not. Diane thanked me for my comment in a tone that closed the subject rather than opening it. "Mrs. Grant, the board is following its process," she said. "We will not litigate HOA business in open comment. Your request is being handled." Harold added that homeowner records requests were subject to review and redaction, and that I would hear back when the review was complete. I asked how long, and Diane said she could not give a date. I sat down with my hands folded in my lap so no one would see them tremble, and I watched Linda Marsh, who was writing in the margins of her papers and not looking up at all. It struck me then that Linda was the only person at that table who looked uncomfortable, and I did not know yet whether that discomfort was for me or for the board, only that it was real and that it set her apart.

News in the same category

The Garden She Plowed Under on Aspen Creek Lane

45 Part