The Garden She Plowed Under on Aspen Creek Lane

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Paul Nguyen, 48, laid the draft on our kitchen table face up and tapped the last page with the cap of his pen, and the sound was louder than it should have been in a house that had gone quiet since the plow had gone through. Tom Grant, 63, stood behind me with his hands on the back of my chair, not quite touching my shoulders, as if he were afraid that any extra weight might tip me over. Outside the kitchen window the front yard was still bare in patches where the blue grama grass had been torn out by the roots, and the rain barrel stood empty beside the house with its lid ajar, and the small stone bench sat crooked where a tire had clipped it. I could see the place where the hand-painted wooden sign reading "Ellie's Garden" had stood, the two post holes dark and damp from the last rain, and I kept looking at them while Paul talked because it was easier than looking at the words on the page.

"I want you to read it as if you were Diane Foster, 62, receiving it," Paul said, and his voice was calm in the way that people who deal with paper for a living learn to be calm. "Not as Ellie Grant, 60, who lived with this garden. As the person who has to answer it."

I read it slowly, my finger following each line. It was addressed to Diane Foster as president of Blue Spruce Estates, to Harold Crane, 65, as treasurer, and to the board as a whole, and it was sent from Paul's office on my behalf, not as a neighbour's complaint but as a formal demand. It asked for three things in plain language, and Paul had insisted on plain language because, as he put it, plain language leaves less room to pretend you misunderstood. First, it demanded that every fine connected to my garden be reversed in writing and removed from my account, and that the association stop enforcing the rule dated 14 April against my property. Second, it demanded a full accounting for the $57,000 described in the budgets as an "irrigation reserve" and for the $43,000 in duplicate invoices from Front Range Landscaping & Paving, with copies of the underlying work orders, bank statements, and board approvals. Third, it demanded that the association preserve all records, including emails, texts, minutes, and drafts, and that it make no further attempt to enter my lot or to alter what remained of the yard until the matter was resolved.

"It also gives them fourteen days," Paul said when I reached the bottom. "Fourteen days to answer in writing. Not a phone call, not a hallway conversation at the mailbox. Writing."

"Will fourteen days be enough for them to invent an answer?" Tom asked.

Paul almost smiled. "Fourteen days is enough for an honest answer. It is also enough time for a dishonest answer to contradict itself, and that is useful too."

Megan Grant, 34, came in from Denver that afternoon with a folder that was already too thick for its clasp, and she spread its contents on the same table after Paul left, lining up the pages in the order we had learned to keep them. She had printed the budget pages where the $57,000 irrigation reserve appeared year after year, carried forward like a piece of furniture nobody ever sat on, and beside them she had placed the invoices from Front Range Landscaping & Paving that matched each other line for line. The same job description, the same quantities, the same amounts, billed twice under different invoice numbers and different dates that were only a few weeks apart. I remembered the first time Rosa Alvarez, 57, had pointed at one pair and said, very quietly, that she had been a nurse for thirty years and she knew what a duplicate chart entry looked like, and this was the financial version of it.

News in the same category

The Garden She Plowed Under on Aspen Creek Lane

45 Part