Tom understands that, even when he teases me about talking to the coneflowers, and he is the one who carried the stones for the bench one at a time from the back of his truck and set them level with a spirit level he has owned since before Megan was born. He is a tall man gone a little stooped from years of pushing brooms and lifting boxes, with hands that are still strong and a habit of fixing things before anyone asks him to, and he retired the same year I did, which meant we suddenly had our mornings together in a way we had not had since we were young. We fell into a rhythm that suited us. I would be out in the garden before the sun got high, with my hat and my gloves and a thermos of coffee going cold beside the bench, and he would be in the garage or on the porch, mending a screen or oiling a hinge, and we would meet for lunch and talk about Megan and the weather and whether the monarchs had found the milkweed yet that year. Our house is not grand, and we never wanted it to be. It is a brick and siding house with a roof Tom re-shingled himself fifteen years ago, a porch swing that creaks in exactly one place, and windows that look out over the garden so that even when I am washing dishes I can see the goldfinches landing on the coneflower heads. That view, that ordinary view, became the center of my days after retirement, and I did not think of it as a statement or a cause. I thought of it as home.
The first time I really understood that other people in Blue Spruce Estates did not see the garden the way I did was at a board meeting in the community room at the end of our street, on a Tuesday evening in late spring when the lilacs were just starting to open and the air smelled faintly of rain. I had gone because Tom had a dentist appointment and because a neighbor had mentioned that the board was going to talk about landscaping, and I thought it would be simple, a discussion about trimming trees or fixing the entrance sign. I sat near the back with Rosa Alvarez, who lives next door at 11 Aspen Creek Lane and who has been my friend since she retired from nursing and moved in with her husband, and Rosa had her phone in her lap the way she always does, ready to photograph anything worth remembering. The room was fluorescent and too warm, with folding chairs and a long table at the front and a pitcher of water that nobody drank, and at the head of that table sat Diane Foster, our HOA president, with a binder open in front of her and a pen in her hand that she tapped, tapped, tapped against the paper while other people talked.
Diane Foster is sixty-two, and I want to describe her fairly, because fairness matters to me even when I am angry, but I also want to describe her truthfully. She is a small, precise woman with short silver hair cut in a sharp bob and glasses that sit low on her nose, and she dresses as if every meeting were a court appearance, in tailored jackets and dark trousers, and she carries herself like someone who believes that order is a moral quality and that a neighborhood, like a household, reveals its character in whether its edges are straight. She is fond of rules in a way that goes beyond liking them. She quotes them. She remembers section numbers. She keeps a copy of the covenants in her binder with tabs in different colors, and when someone speaks out of turn she does not raise her voice, she simply waits, pen tapping, until the room quiets itself, and then she says, "Thank you, let us return to the agenda," in a tone that makes returning to the agenda feel like the only polite option. Harold Crane, our treasurer, sits to her right. He is sixty-five, a retired accountant with a careful mustache and a habit of nodding whenever Diane speaks, as if agreement were part of his job description, and he writes figures in a ledger in neat columns even when the figures have already been printed on the handout. Linda Marsh, our board secretary, sits to her left. She is fifty-eight, quieter than the other two, with brown hair pulled back and reading glasses on a chain, and she takes the minutes in a spiral notebook in her own shorthand, frowning a little as she writes, as if she is trying to get every word down exactly right.