We did not sleep much that night, not because we were celebrating but because the minutes changed what we had to do next. Megan said, "If the rule was never voted on, then the fines built on it need to be looked at, and the money needs to be looked at too." The next morning we went to the association office during its public hours and asked, politely and in writing, for copies of the public HOA budgets for the past four years, the annual financial summaries, and any records of payments to Front Range Landscaping & Paving. The young woman at the desk said she would have to check with the board, and Diane arrived within twenty minutes, as if she had been called, and said the budgets were available to members and that we could have copies for a copying fee. I paid the fee without arguing, because Megan had told me not to give Diane a reason to delay us, and we carried a stack of papers home that smelled faintly of copier toner and sat heavy in Megan's tote. Rosa came over that afternoon with her reading glasses and a magnifying glass she used for seed packets, and the four of us, with Tom making a pot of coffee that lasted until evening, spread the budgets across the kitchen table and the living room floor.
Megan is good with numbers in a patient, unshowy way, and she taught us how to read the budgets as she went. She made a simple spreadsheet on her laptop with columns for the year, the line item, the amount budgeted, the amount reported spent, and the vendor named, and Rosa read figures aloud while Megan typed and Tom checked each page number against a list Megan had made. We started with the most recent year and worked backward, because Megan said the most recent year would show us the shape of the habit. At first the budgets looked ordinary: road patching, clubhouse upkeep, insurance, management fees, landscaping for the common areas. The landscaping line was large but not impossible, and Gary Whitman's company appeared again and again for mowing and trimming and seasonal cleanup, which made sense for a neighborhood with common grass and entrance beds. It was only when Megan sorted the sheet by line item instead of by year that a different shape emerged, a line that repeated without changing much and without ever attaching to a job anyone could remember seeing done.
The line was called irrigation reserve, and the amount attached to it was fifty-seven thousand dollars. It appeared as a reserve set aside for irrigation work on the common areas, and in the following year's budget it appeared again, and then again, carried forward and replenished as if money were being poured into a tank that never emptied and never watered anything. Megan frowned and said, "A reserve is supposed to be for a future job, but if it is spent, there should be a job." We looked for the job. We looked through the vendor lists, through the work orders Rosa remembered from the newsletters, through the photographs Tom had taken of the entrance over the years for no particular reason except that he liked the way the spruce trees looked in snow. There were no new sprinkler heads along Aspen Creek Lane. There were no trenches dug across the common grass. There were no permits for irrigation work filed with the county that Megan could find in the public records she checked online that evening. The common areas were watered, when they were watered at all, by a single old hose bib near the clubhouse and by rain, and the grass in the driest summer had gone brown in patches that everyone had noticed and no one had fixed with fifty-seven thousand dollars' worth of anything.
Rosa walked the common areas with us the next morning, early, before the heat settled, and she pointed out what she knew as a longtime resident. "There has never been an irrigation system here," she said, stopping by a dry patch near the mailbox cluster where the grass crunched under our shoes. "When my husband was alive, he asked about one at a meeting years ago, and they said it was too expensive to install. So where did this reserve come from, and where did it go?" Megan took photographs of the dry patches and of the hose bib and of the entrance beds, which were watered by hand when volunteers remembered, and she added those photographs to the binder under a new tab she labeled Budgets. Tom asked a neighbor who had served on the grounds committee three years earlier whether he remembered any irrigation project, and the man laughed and said the only irrigation he remembered was his own garden hose. By that afternoon, the fifty-seven thousand dollars sat in our notes as a question with no good answer, a line item that behaved like money set aside and money spent at the same time, and Megan wrote in the margin of her spreadsheet, in pencil, "No work found — ask for invoices."