Karen shook her head, a quick, small movement. "It could be a duplicate."
"Does the duplicate have the repair you described?" Byrne asked.
For a moment, no one answered. Ruth stepped forward again, her shoes crunching once on a piece of glass near the curb, and she looked at the key in Karen's palm and then at the photograph on Byrne's device.
"The red cover cracked last winter. I repaired it. Karen said the shape made it easier to find."
Byrne nodded slowly, his eyes moving from Ruth to the photograph to the key. "That repair is described in the report," he said.
Karen's voice rose slightly. "Maybe it was returned."
"By whom?" Byrne asked.
She did not answer.
"When?" he asked.
She looked toward her vehicle again, parked three houses down, beyond the stretch of curb the porch camera covered, as if the answer might be waiting there, or as if she wished she were already walking toward it.
"Where?" Byrne asked.
Karen did not answer that either. Her left hand was still open, but her fingers had begun to tremble, and Marcus could see the brass key catching the light each time her palm moved. Vaughn had taken a step closer to her, not threatening, just present, and Leah had leaned forward in the doorway, her cane pressed hard against the threshold, watching.
Marcus thought about the report again, the one Karen had made on Tuesday morning, the one that had gone out to every homeowner. He thought about the words she had used in it, the serious security concern, the recent hostility toward the board, and he thought about how carefully she had described the key in that report, the split corner, the pale repair line, the tiny black mark, as if she had wanted everyone to know exactly what was missing. He looked at the key in her hand, at the photograph on Byrne's device, and he understood that she had described it so well that there was no room left to pretend it was something else.
Byrne lowered his device and put it back in his pocket. He did not take the key from Karen. He did not need to. It was still there, in her open palm, in plain sight, and the photograph that matched it was now part of the morning, part of the record, part of the scene that Byrne had been reading since he stepped out of the patrol SUV.
Vaughn turned to Karen. "Ma'am, I'll need to see some identification," he said.
Karen stared at him for a moment, as if the request had come from a different conversation entirely. Then she reached for her bag, which hung from her shoulder, and opened it with her right hand. Her left hand was still open, the brass key resting against her palm, and Marcus watched her try to hold the bag open and keep the key visible at the same time, her movements suddenly clumsy.
Byrne turned to Marcus. "Can your porch camera show previous nights?" he asked.
Marcus nodded. "Yes."
"How far back?"
"Long enough for Tuesday."
The words were simple, but they changed the air in the driveway. Karen's hand stopped inside her bag. She did not take anything out. She did not close the bag. She simply stopped, her fingers frozen around whatever she had been reaching for, and looked up at Byrne, then at Marcus, then at the camera mounted beneath the eave above the porch.
"I object to him recording association members," she said. Her voice was sharp now, the authority coming back in a rush, as if she had found a rule she could use. "That camera is an invasion of privacy. He has no right to record people walking on a public sidewalk."
Byrne did not look at her. He kept his eyes on Marcus. "We're asking about activity visible from his property," he said.
Marcus felt the weight of the phone in his pocket, and the weight of the camera above him, and the weight of all the mornings he had spent explaining the same thing to Karen: that the camera showed his walkway, his driveway, and a narrow strip of road, nothing inside another home, nothing behind anyone's fence. He had shown her the view on his phone once, two weeks before, and she had repeated her demand anyway. Now she was repeating it again, in front of two officers, as if repetition would make it true.
Byrne gestured toward the end of the street, toward the common grounds and the service building beyond the hedge. "Show me what the camera sees near the service building," he said.
Marcus shook his head. "It doesn't see the building."
Byrne waited, and Marcus went on, because he knew what the camera did see, and he had known it since the night he installed it, when he had stood on the porch and checked the angle again and again until the frame was right.