He filed the letter in the drawer where he kept the important papers: the deed, the insurance policy, the receipts for the rail and the bench. He put it in a folder by itself, so he would be able to find it again without having to look through everything else. Then he went to the hardware store and bought the lights.
The first quiet weeks after the installation were the best weeks. The lights came on at dusk and went off at the hour he had set on the timer, and no one said anything about them. Neighbors walked past in the evenings and nodded at him when he was on the porch. Leah used the path after sunset without having to ask him to come out and stand at the bottom of the steps. She went to the mailbox in the evening. She sat on the bench and watched the street grow dark, and the lights stayed low and warm around her.
Six weeks passed before the first letter arrived.
Marcus found it in the mailbox on a Tuesday afternoon, a plain white envelope with the association's return address in the corner, the same return address that had been on the approval. He opened it standing in the driveway, because the envelope was thin and he expected it to be a notice about the next meeting or a reminder about the dues. Inside was a single sheet on association letterhead, and the first line stopped him where he stood.
The letter said the association had become aware of unapproved exterior alterations at his address. It said the alterations had been made without the required approval. It said he was to remove them within thirty days or face a fine.
He read it again, more slowly, looking for the part he had misunderstood. Unapproved exterior alterations. He had the approval in the drawer in the kitchen. He had the signature at the bottom of it. He had installed exactly what he had described, in exactly the places he had described, with the fixtures pointed down exactly as he had described. There was nothing in the letter that named the lights. There was nothing in the letter that named any other alteration, because there had been no other alteration. He stood in the driveway with the letter in his hand and the sun on his shoulders and felt the peculiar dislocation of being told, in formal language, that something he knew to be true was not true.
Leah was in the kitchen when he came inside. She was standing at the counter, her cane resting against her right leg, slicing an apple with the slow, deliberate movements she used when she wanted to be sure of her hands. He set the letter down on the counter beside her and did not say anything at first. She read it, put the knife down, and looked at him.
"They approved it," she said. "You have the letter."
"I know," Marcus said.
He went to the drawer and took out the folder with the approval in it. He laid the approval on the table next to the new letter and compared them side by side: the same letterhead, the same address, the same name at the bottom of the approval and, he assumed, the same hand behind the new letter, though the new letter bore no signature he recognized, only a typed name and a title. He made a copy of the approval that evening at the small printer in the corner of the kitchen, and he wrote a reply on a separate sheet of paper.
His reply was short. He stated the date of the application. He stated the date of the approval. He stated that the lights had been installed as approved, in the locations approved, with the specifications approved. He enclosed a copy of the approval bearing Karen Whitmore's signature. He asked that the association correct its records and withdraw the notice. He signed his name at the bottom, folded the pages into an envelope, and mailed it the next morning.
He expected an answer. He expected an apology, or at least an acknowledgment that a mistake had been made. He expected someone from the board to call him and say the letter had gone out in error, that the records had not been updated, that the matter was closed. For two weeks, he checked the mailbox with the same attention he had given it when he was waiting for the approval, and for two weeks there was nothing from the association except a flyer about the common grounds and a notice about the holiday schedule for trash collection.
Then the silence broke, and not in the way he had hoped.