The accountant described duplicate invoices, questionable vendor relationships, incomplete maintenance records, and payments requiring further verification.
Craig interrupted.
"Those vendors were approved through normal procedures."
Arthur looked at him.
"Some were. Others were not."
"That's a matter of documentation."
"Documentation is precisely what we're missing."
Craig leaned forward.
"Are you accusing me of fraud?"
Arthur remained composed.
"I'm not making an accusation. I'm identifying transactions that require investigation."
Naomi added:
"No conclusions have been reached. The independent review will determine whether any policies or laws were violated."
Benjamin listened carefully.
Then he spoke.
"I want to ask a different question."
Everyone turned toward him.
"How many maintenance requests have been closed without the required inspections?"
Arthur checked his notes.
"We don't have a complete figure."
"How many contractors have been paid for work that cannot currently be verified?"
"At least seven transactions require further examination."
Benjamin looked toward Craig.
"How many employees were told that necessary repairs could not be completed because there was no money available?"
Craig frowned.
"I don't know."
Benjamin nodded.
"That's part of the problem."
He opened his briefcase.
Inside were copies of maintenance reports.
He placed them on the table.
"These are reports from the past six months. Several technicians documented equipment failures that were never properly repaired."
Craig looked at the papers.
"Those are routine maintenance matters."
Benjamin pointed toward one entry.
"This is a fire-suppression system inspection."
He moved to another.
"This is an elevator safety issue."
Then another.
"This is a ventilation problem affecting two occupied floors."
Craig looked uncomfortable.
Benjamin continued.
"These are not cosmetic concerns. They involve the safety of people working inside this building."
Richard Sterling examined the documents.
"Why wasn't I informed?"
Benjamin answered quietly.
"Because the reports were marked as completed."
Richard looked toward Craig.
Craig opened his mouth.
But Benjamin raised one hand.
"I'm not asking anyone to make a judgment today. I'm asking that we find out what happened."
Arthur nodded.
"That is exactly what the audit should establish."
Benjamin looked around the table.
"Then let's do it properly."
At 11:55, the meeting reached its most uncomfortable moment.
Naomi placed a document in front of Craig.
"These are the authorization records for several vendor payments."
Craig glanced at them.
"I recognize them."
"Your department approved these transactions."
"Yes."
"Did you verify that the work had been completed?"
Craig shifted in his chair.
"My department relied on contractor confirmations."
"Did anyone inspect the work?"
"That would have been handled by facilities."
Benjamin looked up.
"Facilities was never notified."
Craig turned toward him.
"Then perhaps your department failed to communicate."
Benjamin's expression remained calm.
"Perhaps. That's why we're reviewing the records."
Craig looked frustrated.
"Are you suggesting I personally inspected every repair?"
"No."
"Then how can you hold me responsible?"
Benjamin paused.
"Because responsibility is not the same as personally performing every task."
The room became quiet.
Benjamin continued.
"If you authorize a payment, you are responsible for ensuring the required verification takes place."
Craig looked away.
Richard leaned back.
"Mr. Anderson is correct."
Craig swallowed.
Naomi continued the meeting.
By 12:30, the board had approved several immediate measures.
All questionable vendor payments would be frozen pending verification.
Original records would be preserved.
An independent audit would examine the last three years of transactions.
Maintenance reports would be reviewed by an external engineering firm.
And Craig Holloway would remain temporarily removed from direct purchasing authority.
Craig looked increasingly angry.
But he did not object.
He knew that any further argument would only make his position worse.
At 1:10, the meeting ended.
Most participants left.
Benjamin remained beside the table, organizing his documents.
Richard approached him.
"Benjamin."
"Yes?"
Richard extended his hand.
"I owe you an apology."
Benjamin looked at him.
"For what?"
"For allowing things to deteriorate without asking enough questions."
Benjamin considered the statement.
"Responsibility is shared."
"Perhaps. But I should have paid closer attention."
Evelyn joined them.
"How long have you been working in the building as a facilities employee?"
"Two years."
She smiled faintly.
"And what have you learned?"
Benjamin looked toward the windows.
"More than I expected."
Richard nodded.
"I imagine."
Benjamin closed his briefcase.
"There's one thing I want everyone to understand."
Richard looked at him.
"Go ahead."
"I didn't take this job to catch someone doing something wrong."
He paused.
"I took it because I wanted to know whether this building was still serving the people who work here."
Evelyn smiled.
"And is it?"
Benjamin looked at the conference table.
"Not as well as it should."
At 2:30, Craig returned to his office.
He closed the door.
Then he stood behind his desk, staring at the city.
The revelation had changed everything.
The janitor was the majority owner.
The man he had humiliated had the authority to influence the building's future.
And the independent audit threatened to expose transactions Craig had spent months trying to keep out of sight.