He looked at the stack.
"Why?"
"They said the records relate to the review."
Craig opened the first folder.
His expression tightened.
"Who prepared these?"
"I did."
"Did you include the correspondence?"
"Yes."
"All of it?"
Laura nodded.
"Every email and approval record I could locate."
Craig looked at her.
"Even the internal notes?"
"Yes."
He closed the folder.
"That was unnecessary."
Laura remained composed.
"The preservation request specifically asked for complete records."
Craig stood.
"Laura, you need to understand that not every internal communication is relevant to an accounting review."
She looked at him.
"Then the auditors can decide what is relevant."
Craig stared.
For a moment, he seemed surprised by her answer.
Then he smiled.
"You're becoming very confident lately."
Laura said nothing.
Craig moved around his desk.
"Do you remember who gave you this position?"
"Yes."
"Do you remember who recommended your promotion?"
"Yes."
"Then perhaps you should remember that professional relationships are built on trust."
Laura looked down at the folder.
"I believe trust also requires honesty."
Craig's expression changed.
"Be careful."
Laura nodded.
"I am."
She left the office.
But she had not told him everything.
For several months, she had maintained a private record of unusual instructions.
She had saved emails in which Craig requested that invoices be processed before the completion certificates arrived.
She had kept messages asking her to revise contractor descriptions.
She had also preserved a spreadsheet showing repeated payments to companies whose addresses appeared to overlap.
At first, she had believed these were administrative shortcuts.
Then she had begun noticing that certain vendors were being paid despite incomplete work.
When she asked questions, Craig told her to stop worrying about matters outside her responsibilities.
Now the independent audit had given her an opportunity to explain what she had seen.
She was frightened.
But she was no longer willing to pretend that everything was normal.
The audit uncovers a pattern
At 1:15 p.m., Arthur Collins called Benjamin into the conference room.
Naomi was there.
So was the lead investigator, a woman named Rebecca Shaw.
Rebecca was fifty-five years old and had spent more than twenty years investigating corporate misconduct.
She had a reputation for being thorough and difficult to intimidate.
She greeted Benjamin.
"Mr. Anderson."
"Good afternoon."
"Thank you for making time."
"Of course."
Rebecca opened a large file.
"We've completed the first phase of the vendor review."
Benjamin sat.
"What have you found?"
"Several transactions are inconsistent with the supporting documentation."
She displayed a spreadsheet.
"Between January and September, Pinnacle Tower paid three related vendors for maintenance, equipment procurement, and event support."
Benjamin examined the entries.
"How much?"
"One million and fifty-two thousand dollars across the transactions currently under review."
He looked at Naomi.
"That is more than the original figure."
Naomi nodded.
"We've identified additional payments."
Rebecca continued.
"Some services may have been performed. Others remain unverified. We have also identified duplicate invoice numbers and purchase orders that appear to have been approved after the payment dates."
Benjamin leaned forward.
"Can you establish where the money went?"
"We're tracing the transfers."
"Do you have the bank records?"
"Not all of them. We have requested additional documentation through the appropriate legal channels."
Benjamin studied the spreadsheet.
"Who are the registered owners of these companies?"
Rebecca turned a page.
"One company is registered to an individual named Victor Lane."
Naomi looked up.
"Victor Lane?"
"Yes."
Benjamin remained silent.
Rebecca continued.
"Another is registered to a relative of Mr. Lane. The third uses a management address associated with the same business group."
Arthur added:
"We have not yet established whether the relationship itself represents misconduct. However, the transactions raise questions about disclosure and approval procedures."
Benjamin nodded.
"Continue."
Rebecca displayed another document.
"This is an internal payment authorization."
Benjamin recognized the signature.
Craig Holloway.
He looked at the date.
Then at the amount.
"Did he personally approve this?"
Rebecca nodded.
"The record indicates that he authorized the transaction."
Benjamin leaned back.
For several seconds, he said nothing.
Then he asked:
"Did he receive any money?"
Rebecca answered carefully.
"We have not established that."
"Good. Don't assume it."
She nodded.
"We won't."
Benjamin looked at the screen.
"Find out whether the services were performed. Find out whether the vendors were properly disclosed. And find out whether anyone inside this building was denied necessary equipment while these payments were being made."
Rebecca studied him.
"You're particularly concerned about the maintenance department."
"Because those employees are the people who have to live with the consequences."
He pointed toward the spreadsheet.
"If someone receives money for repairing an elevator, I want to know whether the elevator was actually repaired."
Rebecca closed the file.
"Understood."
The conversation in the basement
That evening, Benjamin found George Ramirez sitting alone in the maintenance workshop.
George was holding an old inspection report.
He looked tired.
"Long day?"
Benjamin asked.
George nodded.
"Long week."
Benjamin sat beside him.
"What's wrong?"
George placed the report on the table.