Craig sat rigidly.
Rebecca continued.
"Victor Lane coordinated several of those submissions. His communications show that he understood inspections were still pending when certain completion documents were being prepared."
Naomi looked toward Victor's empty chair.
"Did he admit that?"
"His written statement acknowledges that documentation was sometimes completed after the work had begun but before final inspection. He describes the practice as administrative convenience."
Arthur shook his head.
"That practice violated the company's procurement controls."
Rebecca turned to the next page.
"Regarding Kenneth Sterling, the review found that he approved payments based on documentation that was, in several cases, incomplete. However, we found no conclusive evidence that he knowingly approved payments for work he knew had not been performed."
Richard exhaled quietly.
Rebecca added an important qualification.
"That does not mean his department fulfilled its responsibilities. The finance department failed to identify repeated exceptions, and several approvals were processed without the required supporting documentation."
Kenneth looked down.
Benjamin asked, "What does the report recommend?"
Rebecca answered carefully.
"First, recovery efforts for any payments determined to be unsupported or improperly billed. Second, referral of potentially fraudulent vendor submissions to appropriate external authorities where the evidence warrants it. Third, disciplinary review for employees whose actions violated company policy. Fourth, a complete redesign of procurement and payment controls."
Benjamin nodded.
"Proceed."
Craig Holloway was invited into the room.
He entered without his usual confidence.
His black tuxedo had been replaced by a dark business suit. He carried a folder and sat across from Rebecca.
Naomi explained that he would have an opportunity to respond.
Craig looked at the report.
"I understand the findings."
Rebecca began.
"Did you authorize completion certifications for work that had not been independently inspected?"
Craig paused.
"In some cases, I relied on vendor confirmations."
"Did you know the inspections were pending?"
"Sometimes."
"Why were payments processed before inspection?"
"We had deadlines. Vendors were threatening to delay service. The building had operational needs."
Arthur looked at him.
"Then why were the invoices recorded as fully completed?"
Craig shifted in his chair.
"That was how the administrative process worked."
"Was that an accurate description?"
Craig did not answer immediately.
"No," he finally said.
The room remained silent.
Rebecca continued.
"Did you instruct Daniel Foster to revise his statement about the gala incident?"
Craig looked toward Naomi.
"I never instructed him directly."
"Did you discuss the statement with Victor Lane?"
Craig hesitated.
"Yes."
"What did you say?"
"I said the situation should be described as an unfortunate misunderstanding."
"Did you know Daniel had witnessed you throw the plate?"
Craig looked down.
"Yes."
"Why did you want his statement changed?"
"I was trying to avoid a scandal."
Benjamin finally spoke.
"Did you believe the incident would become a scandal if Daniel told the truth?"
Craig looked at him.
"I was angry. I made a mistake."
"That is not what I asked."
Craig swallowed.
"I believed the situation would damage my position."
Benjamin nodded.
"Thank you for answering."
Craig looked confused by the response.
Benjamin continued.
"Do you understand why employees were afraid to contradict you?"
Craig looked toward the table.
"I understand that now."
"Did you understand it when you were their supervisor?"
Craig said nothing.
Benjamin waited.
Finally, Craig answered.
"No."
The word was quiet.
But it was the first honest admission he had made during the meeting.
Kenneth Sterling was called next.
He entered carrying a folder of his own.
Rebecca reviewed the findings concerning his department.
"Mr. Sterling, the report does not establish that you knowingly approved payments for work that had not been completed. However, it does establish that your department processed payments without consistently verifying required documentation."
Kenneth nodded.
"I accept that the controls were insufficient."
"Why did you allow exceptions?"
"Quarter-end deadlines were difficult. Operations frequently submitted invoices late, and finance was under pressure to maintain payment schedules."
"Did you personally authorize any payment despite knowing the inspection had not been completed?"
Kenneth looked at the documents.
"I approved payments where the system indicated that the required confirmation had been received. I did not know that some confirmations were being prepared after the payment process had already begun."
Rebecca asked, "Would you have approved them if you had known?"
"No."
Arthur reviewed the supporting emails.
"Your correspondence with Craig specifically stated that payments should not be released without required documentation."
"Correct."
"Yet payments were released."
Kenneth nodded.
"That is a failure of the controls in my department."
Richard looked at his brother.
For twelve years, Kenneth had been the person who ensured the company's financial discipline.
Now he was acknowledging that the system had failed under his supervision.
Kenneth turned toward Richard.
"I should have reviewed the exceptions more closely."
Richard nodded.
"Yes."
There was pain in his expression, but also relief.
The truth was becoming clearer.
And although it was not the answer he had hoped for, it was better than another attempt to hide behind family loyalty.