Arthur Collins leaned forward.
"One important distinction," he said. "An approval signature does not automatically establish that the approver knew the supporting information was inaccurate."
Benjamin nodded.
"Then we should not treat it as proof."
Rebecca continued.
"We also found that certain invoices were submitted through the operations department with completion certificates attached. In several cases, the certificates were signed by individuals who were not responsible for verifying the work."
Naomi looked toward Richard.
"Did Kenneth have direct authority over those procedures?"
"Yes," Richard answered. "He supervised financial controls, payment authorization, and vendor disbursement."
"Did he personally inspect the work?"
Richard shook his head.
"That was not his responsibility. The operations department certified completion. Finance processed payment."
Rebecca pointed to another section.
"That separation may have created an opportunity for abuse. Operations could certify work without adequate verification, while finance could approve payment based on documentation that appeared complete."
Richard stared at the spreadsheet.
"Are you saying Kenneth participated in something?"
"I'm saying the records require a direct explanation from him," Rebecca replied. "We have not reached a conclusion."
Benjamin remained silent for several seconds.
Then he spoke.
"Richard, I want you to understand something. Your brother deserves the same fairness we are extending to everyone else."
Richard looked at him.
"I understand."
"That means no special protection. It also means no special suspicion."
"Agreed."
Benjamin turned toward Naomi.
"Arrange an interview with Kenneth through the independent review team. Richard should not conduct it. Neither should I."
Naomi nodded.
"That is the appropriate approach."
Richard looked uncomfortable.
"My brother may believe this is personal."
"Then explain that the investigation is about financial controls, not family relationships," Benjamin said. "If his approvals were proper, the records should support that. If they were not, we need to understand why."
For the next two hours, the team reviewed the transactions.
One payment involved a ventilation repair on the twenty-seventh floor.
The work order had originally described a significant mechanical failure. A maintenance technician had reported that the system required replacement components and additional testing.
Yet the vendor invoice described the job as a completed emergency repair.
The amount was $18,600.
The building's maintenance records showed that the problem had continued for several weeks.
Another invoice involved elevator maintenance.
A separate payment of $27,400 had been approved for emergency service, but George Ramirez had already informed Benjamin that the requested work had not been completed.
There were also charges for equipment that had never appeared in the building's inventory.
Arthur summarized the pattern.
"These transactions may involve inaccurate certification, inadequate documentation, or services that were never delivered. We need the original records, vendor confirmations, and employee interviews before determining what happened."
Benjamin closed his notebook.
"Then that is what we will obtain."
At noon, Kenneth Sterling arrived.
He entered the conference room wearing a navy suit and carrying a leather briefcase. His expression was controlled, but his eyes moved briefly toward Richard before settling on Rebecca.
"Good afternoon," he said.
Rebecca introduced herself and explained the independent review process.
Kenneth listened without interruption.
When she mentioned the four hundred thousand dollars in transactions, his expression tightened.
"I assume you understand that I approve hundreds of payments every month."
"We do," Rebecca replied.
"Then you understand that I cannot personally inspect every maintenance task."
"Nobody is asking you to."
Kenneth placed his briefcase on the table.
"My responsibility is to ensure that payments follow established financial procedures. When an authorized department submits a completed invoice, finance processes it."
Arthur opened a document.
"Did you know that some of the work orders associated with these invoices remained open after payment?"
Kenneth frowned.
"No."
"Did you know that certain completion certificates were signed by employees who did not have inspection authority?"
"No."
"Did you know that several vendors shared business addresses or administrative contacts?"
Kenneth leaned back.
"I knew that some contractors used shared office facilities. That is not unusual."
Rebecca nodded.
"That may be true. We are examining whether those relationships were properly disclosed."
Kenneth looked toward Richard.
"Have you told them I followed procedure?"
Richard did not answer immediately.
"I told them that we need to examine the records."
Kenneth's expression changed.
"After twelve years?"
"Especially after twelve years," Richard replied.
Silence settled over the room.
Benjamin finally spoke.
"Mr. Sterling, nobody here is asking you to accept responsibility for something you did not do. We are asking you to explain decisions that carry your approval."
Kenneth looked at him.
For a moment, he seemed to recognize the older maintenance worker who had once entered the gala carrying a waste collection cart.
"You're the janitor," Kenneth said.
Benjamin did not react.
"I am Benjamin Anderson."
"I know who you are now."
"Then you know why the records matter."
Kenneth glanced at the documents.
"I approved payments based on information provided by operations. If someone submitted false completion certificates, that is an operations issue."