The first thing was the food, because in a house the food is where love keeps its accounts, and the accounts had stopped balancing sometime in the spring.
It began with the seconds. Ruby was not a big eater; she never had been. Pearl had been the hungry one — that was the sort of sentence that still ambushed him at odd moments, four years on, in the cereal aisle, in his truck at a red light: Pearl had been the hungry one, the one who finished and looked around with her spoon still up, and Ruby had been the dawdler, the dreamer over the plate, the one who had to be coaxed through a chicken leg. And so when Ruby, sometime around the end of April, began asking for second helpings — politely, reasonably, looking him in the eye across the table — Desmond had felt a small, foolish bloom of pleasure before he felt anything else. Growth spurt, Tanya said. She's six, she's all legs, look at her. Francine, serving, had smiled her housekeeper's smile and filled the plate again without comment, the way she had filled plates in that kitchen for six years, and Desmond had eaten his own supper in a glow of fatherly contentment while his daughter carried her appetite upstairs like a prayer being answered.
Except that the appetite never showed. That was the thing he noticed next, in the slow, electrician's way of noticing — not all at once, but as a pattern assembling itself out of small repeated facts. Ruby asked for seconds and grew no rounder. Ruby asked for seconds and then, at the end of the meal, her plate — wait. That was just it. Her plate was never there at the end of the meal to be looked at. On the nights she asked for more she had developed the habit of finishing in the kitchen, or taking the plate to the sink herself like a little waitress, or — on Tuesdays, and he would think later about the Tuesdays — asking to be served first and take her supper upstairs to her desk because the dining room was too loud, because she had a book, because because. And the food in the refrigerator had begun to go missing in a way that had no culprit. Half a meatloaf, gone. The end of a casserole under its foil, planed away level as a field. A rotisserie chicken from the store reduced, by morning, to a carcass picked cleaner than any Price had ever picked it — and Desmond, who rose at five and stood in the light of that refrigerator with his coffee, had done what a man does: he had blamed the most available suspect. Himself. Night eating. Thirty-eight years old, a gut starting, a man under the ordinary sorrows — sure. He started leaving himself notes on the fridge in his own handwriting, which his wife found and did not mention, because in a house with a grief in it, everybody is allowed a few mysteries, and the mysteries are a kind of mercy.
There had been other signs, and he had folded every one of them away with a tenderness that looked, from the outside, exactly like being a good father. Her teacher, Ms. Okafor, had kept him two minutes after pickup in May with the careful face teachers make when the news is small but not nothing: Ruby was falling asleep at her desk in the afternoons. Not disruptive, not ill — just gone, mid-lesson, head down on folded arms like a child twice as worked. And she was hoarding, a little. Crackers in her desk from the snack basket. An apple in her cubby, two days running, turning. "She says she's saving them," Ms. Okafor said, "for later. She won't say later for what." Desmond had thanked her and carried the information home the way he carried everything that spring: privately, meaning to find the moment to lay it beside Tanya's share of the worry, and the moment had never come, because in the Price house there was a rule nobody had ever spoken aloud, which was that you did not hand your wife a new fear about the living child until you had some idea what it was, because the old fear about the dead one still filled the room whenever a door was opened on it. So he watched instead. Watching was his answer to everything that spring. He watched Ruby eat like a bird and ask like a lumberjack. He watched her grow tired and pale and strangely competent — there was a capability in her that season which had nothing to do with school, the capability of a person running a small, serious operation — and he filed it all, hum by hum, flicker by flicker, in the dark drawer of his attention, and told himself the drawer was enough.