"I want you both to understand why." Dr. Weyland's voice was even, almost lecturing, the voice he used for the public talks in San Tomas. "The sky-survey contract pays for the plate program. It pays for Mr. Reyes's position. It paid for the new drive on the thirty-six-inch, and it pays for half the coal we burn in winter and the roof over this building." Dr. Weyland's gaze moved to the framed photograph on the wall, the dome under construction, the workmen small as ants. "I came here in nineteen thirty-eight, when this place was one telescope and a dream and a water tank that leaked. I kept it alive through the war, when half my staff went to Los Alamos and didn't come back, and I developed plates alone through the winter of forty-four with the pipes frozen and the darkroom at forty degrees. And through the lean years after, when the university money stopped and stopped for good, and I wrote letters —" his voice roughened slightly — "I wrote a hundred letters to keep the doors open. I kept it alive by being the man the Air Force could rely on." He paused. "I am not going to lose it now. Not to stubbornness. Not to —" He searched for the word. "Not to sentiment."
He looked at Ruth. "You do fine work, Miss Calloway. The finest measuring I have ever supervised. But this is my decision to make, and I have made it. On Monday the October plates go to White Sands."
The radiator ticked again. Outside, a truck changed gears on the mesa road.
Ruth listened to the end. She had decided, walking across the compound in the cold, that she would listen to the end. Then she said, quietly, "Dr. Weyland, I should tell you that duplicate prints of the October plates already exist, off the mesa."
Something changed in his face. Daniel's cap stopped turning in his hands.
"I made a complete set of duplicate prints," Ruth said, "and mailed them by registered mail last week to Dr. Vera Lindqvist in Pasadena. My former teacher." She saw the question forming on his face and answered it. "A retired astronomer, sixty-eight years old, and a woman who has kept every plate she ever took and every letter she ever received, filed by date, in a fireproof cabinet she had built into her study wall. I was her student for four years. If there is one person in America I trust with a record, Dr. Weyland, it is Vera Lindqvist. The parcel is in her keeping now, and she has written back to say so."
Dr. Weyland stared at her. "You did this — without my authority."
"I did it as a scientist," Ruth said. "The originals are the observatory's property, and I have never disputed that. The record of what the sky showed is not any one man's property to erase."
"You had no right—"
"And Miss Lawson," Ruth went on, in the same quiet tone. "Peggy Lawson, of the Albuquerque Herald. I have told her nothing on the record. But she has seen the logbook entry — Object CA-1 — and she is a reporter, Dr. Weyland. She knows there is a story, though not its details. She is staying on in San Tomas." Ruth folded her hands in her lap, the way he had folded his. "If the originals go to White Sands on Monday and do not come back, the discovery still exists in Pasadena, and in a reporter's notebook. I won't be the person who erased a discovery. Not for the contract. Not for anyone."
The silence that followed was complete. Daniel cleared his throat.
"Sir," he said, from by the bookcase. "She's right."
Dr. Weyland turned on him. "You knew about this?"
"I knew about the object, sir. I operated the thirty-six-inch on those October nights. My initials are in the log beside hers." Daniel's voice was steady, the ex-Navy steadiness that never rose and never hurried. "I didn't know about the parcel to Pasadena until this minute. But she's right, and you know it, sir."
"Do I?" Dr. Weyland was on his feet now, and the level lecturer's voice was gone. "Do I know it, Reyes? You'd throw away your own position — the position that contract pays for — for a point of pride? You've got a mother in San Tomas and a correspondence course in engineering and exactly one job in this state that lets you do both. Does she understand what she's asking me to risk? Do you?"
"I understand it better than most, sir," Daniel said quietly. "It's my job on the table too."
"Then act like it!" Dr. Weyland turned on Ruth. "Thirty years of work, Miss Calloway. The finest small observatory in the Southwest, built plate by plate, and you would gamble it on — on arithmetic and stubbornness!"
Ruth met his eyes. "It's the same arithmetic the contract pays me to do, Dr. Weyland," she said. "I'd rather thought that was the point of it."
For an instant Daniel's mouth twitched, and ruthlessly suppressed the twitch. Dr. Weyland stared at her, and something in his face — fury, or the effort of containing it — seemed to crack and show the weariness underneath.
"It's not pride, sir," Daniel said. "It's the work."
"Don't you lecture me about the work!" Dr. Weyland's hand came down on the desk, and the pipes jumped in their stand. "I was doing the work when you were in short trousers! I know what the work costs!"
He stood there breathing hard, his face flushed, his hand still flat on the blotter. Ruth did not flinch. She had seen men angry before — professors, mostly, men who mistook volume for argument — and she had learned long ago that anger, like a plate flaw, was usually a sign of something straining underneath.
The anger went out of him as quickly as it had come. He sat down. He looked at his hand on the blotter as if surprised to find it there, and then at the two of them, standing and sitting before him like pupils called up for a scolding.
For a moment — just a moment, no longer — he saw the room the way a stranger might have seen it: an old man behind a desk, sixty-one years old and afraid, trying to frighten two people younger than himself into helping him stay afraid. He had spent his life building a place where the truth could be looked at squarely, and now he was asking the two people who did the looking to look away. He thought of himself at twenty-six, measuring plates through the night in a cold dome in Massachusetts, certain to the bone that the work mattered more than the comfort of the men who paid for it. He had been so certain then. He wondered when he had stopped being certain, and whether anyone had noticed the exact night, the way Ruth would have noticed it on a plate — the point where the line bent.
He let out a long breath. "Sit down, Reyes," he said quietly. Daniel sat.
Dr. Weyland looked at Ruth. When he spoke again, the anger was gone, and what was left was something she had not heard from him before: a plain, unadorned curiosity, the kind she remembered from her own teachers on the days they forgot to be important.
"Your decay figures," he said.
"Sir?"
"You wrote in the log that the orbit is decaying. That it won't stay up." He leaned forward. "When does it come down, Miss Calloway?"
Ruth felt Daniel's eyes on her. She chose her words the way she chose her measurements: carefully, and without embellishment.