"Morning," he said, without looking down. "Your extra plates are in the darkroom. Two fields on the tenth, same as the eighth. One long, one short."
"Did anyone ask what the extra exposures were for?"
"Nobody asks me anything before noon." He climbed down, wiping his hands on a rag. "I logged them as survey repeats. Which they are, if anybody wants to be technical about it."
"Thank you, Daniel."
He shrugged, the way he did when thanks embarrassed him. "You want the big glass on that field some night, it's yours for an hour. Just say when."
She wanted to tell him what the dots meant. The words were right there — forty seconds, tumbling, not a rock — but Weyland had told her to keep it quiet, and Daniel's job depended on the survey contract, and she had learned, in six years on the mesa, that a secret told too early became everybody's property and nobody's responsibility. "When it's time," she said. "I'll say when."
He nodded as if that were a complete answer, and went back to his bearing.
Ruth spent the afternoon at her desk with the logbook, the scratch pad, a slide rule, and the little brown volume of logarithm tables that had belonged to her father. He had taught physics at the high school in Ohio for thirty years and had given her the tables when she left for college, inscribed in his careful hand: For Ruth, who will check the arithmetic.
She laid out the crossing times. On the night of the sixth, the object had crossed the reference field at 11:42 in the evening. On the eighth, at 9:56. On the tenth, at 8:10. The intervals were not twenty-four hours; they were shorter, and they shortened in a way that had a shape to it. She worked the shape out with the slide rule, checking each step against the tables, and the shape said: ninety-six minutes — and each circuit came a little sooner than the last, the way a stone sinks faster as it nears the bottom of a pond.
She sat very still. A ninety-six-minute period meant it was low — a few hundred miles up, no more. And the quickening meant the orbit was not a circle but an ellipse, and the low end of the ellipse was dragging in the thin top of the air, losing a little height with every pass. Elliptical and decaying. Asteroids did not decay. That was not anything nature made.
It was something somebody had put up there.
She wrote it in the logbook under Object CA-1, in the same neat hand she used for everything: Period approx. 96 min. Orbit elliptical, decaying. Brightness cycle approx. 40 sec — tumbling. Conclusion: artificial. Then she stared at the word artificial until it stopped looking like a word at all.
Nobody had announced it. That was the part that sat cold in her stomach. When the Russians put up Sputnik, they had announced it to the whole world within the hour — the beeping was the point. An object in a decaying orbit, tumbling, unannounced, over New Mexico, in October of 1957 — and there was a proving ground two hundred miles south at White Sands, and everybody on the mesa knew that what went up from there was not always admitted afterward.
Dr. Weyland came in with his hands clasped behind his back, the way he always did when inspecting something he did not fully understand.
"Still chasing your phantom, Miss Calloway?" he asked, peering at the comparator.
"Still measuring it, Dr. Weyland." She kept her voice level. "The survey plates are on schedule. The October fields will be finished by the twentieth."
"Good, good." He picked up the logbook, glanced at the page, and set it down again without comment — or rather, with the particular absence of comment he used when he had decided not to ask a question. "You know my feeling, Ruth. Nine times in ten these things are emulsion flaws. But you are thorough, and thoroughness is never wasted. Just — " he hesitated at the door — "keep it among ourselves for the present. Until we know what it is, there is no need to excite anyone."
"Of course," she said.
After he left, she sat for a long time with her hands folded on the logbook. She understood what he was protecting. The sky-survey contract paid for the plates, the chemicals, the comparator — and for Daniel's salary, and half of her own. The contract came from the Air Force. If the Air Force had put something up and lost it, the last thing Dr. Weyland wanted was his own observatory making a fuss about it. She did not blame him for the caution. She only wished the numbers were less certain.
But the numbers were certain. Forty seconds. Ninety-six minutes. Decaying.
She checked the arithmetic a third time, although she knew she would find nothing wrong with it. That was the trouble with being thorough: when the answer frightened you, thoroughness gave you nowhere to hide.
That evening she stood at the mesa edge after supper and looked down at San Tomas, the little grid of lights in the valley. Somewhere down there, children were tuning crystal sets to hear a beep from a Russian satellite. Up here, above them all, an unannounced piece of somebody's engineering was falling out of the sky one orbit at a time, and she was the only person on earth who had measured it. The thought should have frightened her. Instead it steadied her, the way a difficult calculation steadied her: here was a thing that could be worked, step by step, until it gave up its answer.
She went inside and took out her writing paper.
She had been putting off the letter for three days, telling herself she needed one more night's plates. But the arithmetic was checked, and what she needed now was a judgment older and steadier than her own — and there was exactly one person she trusted with an unfinished thought.
She wrote it by hand, in ink, because Dr. Vera Lindqvist was sixty-eight and retired in Pasadena and had taught Ruth spherical astronomy fifteen years ago, and some teachers deserved ink.
"Dear Dr. Lindqvist," she wrote. "I hope you will forgive a letter out of the blue from a former student. I have found something in our survey plates that I cannot make fit any honest category, and I need a judgment better than my own..."
She set it all down: the ninth-magnitude point that belonged to no catalog, the dotted trail, the forty-second cycle measured twice, the ninety-six-minute period, the quickening that meant a decaying ellipse. She enclosed her tables — times, estimated magnitudes, the computed elements — folded neatly. She did not claim a discovery. She had been at Cerro Alto long enough to know that claiming came later, if it came at all, and usually belonged to someone else.
"I have been asked to say nothing for the present," she wrote, "and I will honor that. But I could not bear to let the numbers sit unexamined, and there is no one whose eye I trust as I trust yours. I ask you to keep this between us for now. In confidence, as ever, your student, Ruth Calloway."