so thick it made the council's ordinary correspondence look like napkins,
from a firm in Charlottesville with three names and a fountain pen flourish,
and Peg — because it was addressed to the council and was therefore, once
received, a public document — showed it to Adam at the counter on Monday
morning with the air of a woman performing a civic duty she was privately
enjoying to the marrow.
The letter claimed, with courtesy and footnotes, that Beatrice Wexford held
Wexford Lane by prescriptive right. Twenty years and more of open,
notorious, continuous, exclusive control: the signs, the chain, the dues
collected, the permissions given and withheld — the very record Adam and
the Gazette had assembled, reframed as the elements of a legal claim, each
casserole-story cudgel turned into a fence post. And it attached, as its final
exhibit, a photocopy yellowed soft as cloth: a letter on town letterhead dated
August 1978, from Mayor Harlan Cobb, thanking the Wexford family —
thanking Ernest Wexford by name — "for the gift of the street," and
expressing the town's gratitude for the family's generosity "in making
Wexford Lane over to the people of Goshen Falls."
"She's arguing the letter proves it stayed theirs," Adam said. He was reading
with his finger under the lines, the way he read medication orders, twice.
"That the town never took it. That it was — courtesy. A compliment, not a
conveyance."
"She's arguing the letter because it's the only paper she has," Peg said. "Read
the other thing."
The other thing was a memorandum, four pages, from Nancy Greer, town
63
attorney, to the mayor and council, marked with a file number and stamped
as received, and it dismantled the Charlottesville letter the way a good nurse
dismantles a bad dressing — from the edges, without hurry, exposing
everything.
A dedication of land to public use, Greer wrote, once made in the statutory
form and accepted by the governing body, is irrevocable. The plat of March
1979, Plat Book 9, page 41, bore the dedication in Ernest Wexford's own
hand and signature; the council's acceptance was entered in the minutes of
the meeting of March 20, 1979; the lane had been maintained at public
expense in the years since, as the town's own road ledgers — which Greer
cited by year, eleven of them — attested. What a man gives to the public in
writing, before witnesses, and records in the county's own books, his heirs
cannot ungive by hanging a chain across it, however long the chain hangs.
Prescription, the memo continued, does not run against a public street. It
never has. The doctrine exists to quiet titles between neighbors; it does not
exist to let a citizen fence a road out of the public's hands by standing in it
long enough, and the cases that say so were listed with the flat abundance of
a woman laying out every instrument before the operation. The public cannot
lose its street by neglect, by courtesy, or by the repeated failure of its clerks
to answer letters — a sentence Adam read twice, and thought about fourteen
files, and thought about Peg Sullivan standing on the other side of the
counter not looking away from it.
And the Cobb letter. Greer saved it for last, the way you save the heart for
last. The letter is, she wrote, not Bea Wexford's evidence. It is the town's. A
gift is a transfer. A man does not thank his neighbor for a gift the neighbor
still owns. Mayor Cobb's courtesy, in 1978, in anticipation of the recorded
dedication the following spring, states in the plainest of words that the street
64
was made over — past tense, accomplished fact — to the people of Goshen
Falls. The family's own exhibit establishes the family's own act. The letter is
the dedication wearing a thank-you note, and the town is obliged to Mrs.
Wexford's counsel for producing it, as it completes the record.
Peg leaned on the counter. "Nancy Greer," she said, "has been waiting eleven
years for somebody to make her write that memo. You could hear the
typewriter smiling." She gathered the pages with a clerk's neatness and
tapped them square. "It'll all be read into the record on the eighteenth. The
lawyer from Charlottesville is invited to attend and be heard. So's she." A
pause. "So are you."
"Does she know?" Adam said. "Bea. About the memo."
"She'll have a copy from her own counsel by now." Peg's face did something
complicated and not unkind. "Forty-six years she's kept that letter in a drawer
like it was a deed, Adam. Forty-six years of believing the paper said mine.
And the paper says gift. I find I can't enjoy that as much as I thought I would
on Friday."
Adam drove home by the long way, out of a habit so old he was halfway up
Miller's Crossing before he noticed he had done it, the road not taken so
thoroughly not-taken that his hands had turned the wheel themselves. He
thought about a woman of seventy-four alone in a farmhouse with a yellowed
letter, reading a lawyer's memo over and over the way he had read Lily's
discharge papers, looking for the line that said it would be all right, and not
finding it, because it wasn't there. First, the breathing, he thought. Everybody
in this story is holding their breath. That was no way to keep a street, or a
town, or a family, or anything at all.
Elaine Wexford came on a Saturday, in a gray sedan with Richmond plates,
65
and she did not go to the farmhouse first.