came down his own road," Felix said. "And Ernest said: 'A street you have to
83
keep isn't a street. It's a driveway with an audience.' He said it just like that,
and the room laughed — I laughed — and he let us laugh, and then he said
the other thing quieter, so I don't know that the minutes got it, and the
minutes were my job that spring, so I can say for a fact they didn't." He
looked down at the lectern for a moment, at his own hands on it. "Afterward,
in the hall, he was rolling up his copy of the plat and I said something foolish
— I was twenty-eight, I said a good many foolish things in an official
capacity — I said, 'Mrs. Wexford might have an opinion about giving away
her street.' And Ernest said: 'Bea likes to think it's hers. Let her think it.
Thinking never hurt a plat map.'" Felix's voice, which had held all the way
down the long aisle of the story, thinned at the very end, not with feeling
exactly — with accuracy. "I've thought about that sentence for forty-six
years, every time I drove past that chain. Six years the lane sat open after he
signed it. Then the signs went up, and the chain, and I drove past it and said
to myself, thinking never hurt a plat map. I believe he meant it as a kindness.
And I am sorry it took a child's ambulance to get me up out of my chair to
say what the kindness cost."
He sat down to no applause — the room had the sense, collective and
unspoken, that applause would have been a kind of weather too.
Bea's lawyer rose then. His name was Mr. Halsey and he did his work well
and without relish, which Adam found he respected. The prescriptive-rights
argument he laid down in four clean sentences: forty years of open,
notorious, continuous control; the chain maintained; the signs posted; the
town's own fifteen complaints closed without action — acquiescence, he
called it, and the word landed in the room like a plow blade finding a stone.
Then he produced the letter. It had come to light, he said, in the family's
papers, and he offered it as the context in which the Wexford family's
84
understanding of the lane had been formed and kept: a letter to Ernest
Wexford, dated April 1978, eleven months before the dedication, from the
then-mayor, Harlan Cobb. He held it up: one page, town letterhead, a
signature under a typewritten name. "We ask that the letter be entered into
the record," Mr. Halsey said, "as evidence of the understanding between the
town and the family."
Nancy Greer stood before he had finished sitting. "The town joins in that
request," she said, pleasantly. "We ask only that it be read as it was offered:
whole, and aloud." A pause developed in the room, the kind that has a pulse.
Mr. Halsey looked down at his own page as though it had been re-dealt to
him from a different deck. Mayor Price said, "The clerk will read the letter,"
and Ms. Ferreira took it in both hands and read it in her level voice, and
Adam watched a courtesy do the work of a survey.
"April 3, 1978. Dear Ernest," the clerk read. "I write for myself and for the
council to thank you and your family, before the fact and from the heart, for
the gift of the street. When the plat is recorded next spring, Wexford Lane
will belong to every citizen of Goshen Falls, and it will have come to them
not by purchase and not by taking but by the generosity of the Wexfords,
which this town will remember as long as the lane is driven. Bea's
mother-in-law planted the maples along it with her own hands, and I hope
you will tell Bea that no deed we record can make the lane any less the
Wexfords' in the town's affection — but in the town's law, and on the town's
map, it will be the public's, which is what you have asked of us, and what we
are proud to accept. With gratitude, Harlan Cobb, Mayor."
The word gift went through the room the way the report's seven minutes had
gone through it: slowly, and at the level of the floorboards. Gift. A gift is a
thing given away, and a thing given away cannot be kept, and the letter that
85
was to have proven the family's understanding proved, read whole and aloud,
that the understanding had been written down for them, kindly and
completely, in 1978, by the mayor himself, and filed in their own drawer for
forty-six years. Adam did not look at Bea. He looked at Elaine, standing at
the back wall by the coats, and Elaine was looking at her mother's hands on
the pocketbook, and her face had in it a thing Adam had seen in hospital
rooms at the moment a diagnosis finally lands: grief, and underneath the
grief, unmistakable in its plainness, relief — because a thing that has landed
can be picked up, and carried, and set down somewhere chosen. Nancy Greer
sat down without another word. She did not need one. On the wall above the
council table the plat still glowed, and the signature, and the words
DEDICATED TO PUBLIC USE, in letters six inches tall, over all of it.
The council was preparing, with the small shufflings of a body getting ready
to deliberate, to move to discussion, when Bea Wexford stood up.