Claire entered it in the promise book that same evening. Entry number one. The book — a bound ledger with numbered pages that Anna Reyes had found, of all places, in the old repair archive — required the entry in ink: the date, the complaint in the complainant's own words where possible, the name of the person who would answer it, and the date by which the answer would be given. Seven days. She wrote her own name in the answer column, and then sat at the kitchen table of the flat above the store until nearly midnight composing three sentences that were true, which is harder than composing thirty that are kind.
The answer said that the salon was closing because the room it occupied had been a workshop before it was a salon, and that the store was restoring the workshop. It said Mrs. Ashford's viewings would be held on the mezzanine, with the same staff and the same discretion, and that Claire would attend the first one personally. And it said — Claire had written this sentence four times before she let it stand — that a store which could not repair what it sold had no business asking anyone to buy more of it.
She had not asked Anna whether the letter was wise. She had asked whether it was accurate, and Anna, reading it once, slowly, had said: "It's the first letter this store has sent in two years that a person could check." From Anna Reyes, that was the equivalent of a parade.
Now the dust covers were coming off the benches.
There were six of them, in two rows of three, facing the window the way they had always faced it, and the covers had been put on by someone — Claire chose to believe it had been someone reluctant — with a certain care: each bench shrouded separately, the drawers closed, the lamps folded down like sleeping birds. Henry went along the row with a penknife and cut the twine at each cover's throat, and he did not hurry.
Under the covers the benches were as he had left them. That was the thing nobody had expected, and it undid him more than damage would have. The leather aprons still hung at their hooks. The bench pins were still in place, worn by hands before his — a bench pin outlives the jeweler the way a road outlives the cart. His flex-shaft machine hung at the first bench where he had left it on the last day. The drawers, when he opened them, gave back the smell of the room as it had been: metal dust and leather and polishing compound, and underneath all of it, cedar, because some master before him had lined the tool drawers with cedar against the damp.
"They didn't sell the benches," he said at last. "I thought they'd sell the benches."
"Halstead tried," Anna said from the doorway. "Twice. The first buyers wanted them for a restaurant — atmosphere. The second wanted to export them. Both times the paperwork came to me and I — " she paused, with the air of a woman deciding how much of her own file to read aloud " — I processed it slowly. There's a difference between losing something and mislaying the forms for losing it. I mislaid the forms."
Henry looked at her for a moment. Then he nodded, once, and went back to his inventory.
He inventoried for two days, on paper, in pencil, in a hand so regular it might have been set in type: each bench, each drawer, each tool, present or absent, sound or wanting. The management watched the list grow on his clipboard and understood, gradually, that they were watching an audit of a theft conducted at the speed of policy. The good saws were gone — sold, the records said, as surplus, in a lot with the salon's first furniture order, as though the tools and the chairs had been the same kind of thing. The goldsmith's stakes were gone. The drawers held the lesser tools, the duplicates, the worn: a bench room the way a library remains after the rare books have been taken — shelves intact, reading room swept, the collection's heart removed with a signature.
On the second afternoon Claire found him standing at the third bench with a small tin in his hand.
"Yours?" she said.
"Mine," he said. "Left in a drawer on purpose, the day we closed. A man leaves something of his in a room he's not finished with. It's not superstition. It's a note to himself." Inside the tin, nested in cotton gone yellow, were three gravers, their handles polished by a grip she would have known anywhere. "I told myself if I ever stood here again I'd want these where my hand could find them. I didn't tell anybody. A note you tell people about is just a speech."