Two Private Patrolmen in Police Uniforms Struck a Retired Engineer With a Baton on His Own Front Lawn

Chapter 18

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The public positions of the other parties arrived, as such positions do, through counsel, in writing, and were noted by the local press with the care that small-city journalism brings to a story with a video in it. Sentinel Community Patrol, through its attorneys, stated that the incident was a serious departure from the firm's standards and training, that the officers involved had been placed on leave pending the firm's internal review, that the firm cooperated fully with the Scottsdale police, and that it would be inappropriate to comment further on matters under review. Scott Draper, through the same counsel, stated that he had acted in the belief that he was preventing a vehicle from being removed from an active compliance stop, that the resident had refused lawful direction, and that he regretted the injuries that resulted; the statement used the word lawful once and the word direction three times, and Ivers, reading it aloud, observed that a private security guard's direction was lawful in the same way that a lifeguard's parking ticket was a naval blockade, and then apologized for the sentence, because she made a rule of not enjoying herself in front of clients. Deb Kaine, through counsel retained by the association's insurer, stated that her email had concerned routine visible patrol presence, that the phrase in question had been an unfortunate choice of words, that she had neither ordered nor contemplated any physical enforcement, that the compliance file reflected the department's good-faith records, and that she had left the scene on the day in question upon the arrival of emergency services. The statement did not mention the registration, or the insurance, or the sixty days. George read all three statements at his kitchen table, in the evening, with the notebook beside him out of habit, and he found that he had nothing to write in it. The statements were not lies, exactly, he thought. They were something more durable than lies. They were the sound of the gradient, still descending, each step describing itself as routine, all the way down.

The board of the Saguaro Ridge homeowners association met in emergency session eleven days after the incident, in the community center's main hall, in the room where the annual meetings and the holiday parties and the yoga classes were held, and the minutes of that session, which were later produced and entered into more than one file, record an attendance that the room had never held for a yoga class. Residents stood along the back wall. The Hendersons came, and Grace Liu, and the young father from Mesquite Hollow whose moving pod had started his acquaintance with the compliance office, and Helen and Diego Ortiz sat in the second row with the formality of witnesses. George did not attend. His ribs had voted against folding chairs, and Alicia, who attended in his place with his file in her bag and his instructions in her ear, reported the evening to him afterward in the order it had happened, and the minutes, when they came, agreed with her account in every particular that minutes are capable of agreeing with, which is to say the motions and the votes and not the temperature.

The temperature, by Alicia's account, was set early, by the board's own counsel, a gray man from a Phoenix firm who opened the session by advising the members, in the presence of the residents, that certain matters were under police review and insurance review and would not be discussed in their particulars, and that the board's business that evening was governance. It was Howard Stein who surprised the room, and perhaps himself. Stein had chaired the board for three years and had declined to sign the petition on his patio with courtesy and a glass of iced tea, and he had spent the eleven days since the incident, as he told the room in a statement he had clearly written out and just as clearly departed from, reading the association's own files, which he described as an education he should not have needed a man in a hospital to receive. He moved, himself, the motions that the session would be remembered for. That the enforcement provisions of the Sentinel contract be suspended immediately, and the patrol confined to the observation and reporting functions described in its scope, pending a full review of the contract and its performance. That the fine ledger against the Freeman property be voided in its entirety, and the account corrected to zero, and that a review of all open compliance fines be commissioned from an outside firm, with the files produced to it unedited. That the association's insurer and counsel be directed to preserve every record of the compliance department and the patrol, including electronic records, without exception. The motions were seconded by Linda Chao, who had carried a warning to George in April in the tone of a friend and who voted now with the air of a woman paying a debt she had assigned herself. They passed, four to one, the dissent coming from a member who said, for the minutes, that the board was acting in haste under public pressure, a sentence the minutes preserved and the room received in a silence that had its own opinion.

News in the same category

Two Private Patrolmen in Police Uniforms Struck a Retired Engineer With a Baton on His Own Front Lawn

45 Part