Two Private Patrolmen in Police Uniforms Struck a Retired Engineer With a Baton on His Own Front Lawn

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The civil filing was lodged in the Superior Court in the first week of June, and it was, as filings are, a document that attempted to translate an afternoon into a list. Rachel Ivers had drafted it the way she drafted everything, as if a hostile reader with a pencil would go over it in a conference room, which is precisely what would happen. It named the association, its management company, Sentinel Community Patrol, Scott Draper, and Deb Kaine. It set out the spring in numbered paragraphs, each paragraph carrying a date, and it attached as exhibits the things that made the dates undeniable: the contract, with the limitations section flagged; the marketing binder page; the compliance file, complete, with the registration and the insurance sitting in the back of it like a rebuttal that had been filed early and ignored; the sixty-day ledger; the petition with its forty-one signatures; the email; the patrol log; the emergency room record; the police report; and the two recordings, itemized and described in the flat language that courts prefer, as if a baton coming down in a driveway in the late light could be adequately introduced as Exhibit L. George read the complaint at the conference table before it was filed, slowly, with the pencil he was allowed to use on his own copy, and he found the experience strange in a way he had not anticipated: his life, his truck, his wife's death in the background of the restoration paragraphs, all of it set in the typeface of the law, accurate and airless. At the paragraph that described his injuries he stopped, and Ivers, watching him, said that the language was the language the forum required, and that the forum's coldness was not the same as indifference, and that in her experience it was sometimes the coldest rooms that kept the record straightest. He signed the verification, and Alicia drove him home, and that evening he did the breathing exercises the hospital had prescribed, standing at the kitchen window, watching the light go off the mountains in sections, like a building being closed for the night.

Discovery, which is the long middle of every civil case, had the texture of the spring replayed at the speed of mail. Interrogatories arrived in sets, and were answered in sets, and the answers had the quality of statements made through several thicknesses of counsel. Depositions were noticed and rescheduled and noticed again. The association's insurer appointed its own lawyers, who appointed their own experts, and Sentinel's insurer did the same, and there arrived in Ivers's office, in the fullness of procedural time, a biomechanics report, commissioned by a carrier, which analyzed the doorbell recording frame by frame and concluded that the force used had been, in its phrase, within the range the firm's training materials described for a compliance hold, a conclusion that required the reader to overlook that the firm's contract forbade the hold, the contact, and the occasion. Ivers sent the report to George with a note in her own hand, which said only: they have begun by defending the swing; we will end by discussing the contract. He kept the note in the drawer. He had begun to understand that the case, like the fine programme before it, was a machine for converting events into paper, and that his advantage, such as it was, was that he had never expected anything else and had kept the better paper from the beginning, in a kitchen drawer, in pencil, with the dates on it.

News in the same category

Two Private Patrolmen in Police Uniforms Struck a Retired Engineer With a Baton on His Own Front Lawn

45 Part