Nick Ferris gave his deposition in the autumn, in a conference room in Tempe, with Sentinel's counsel beside him and a court reporter at the end of the table turning his voice into the record at two hundred words a minute. George did not attend, on Ivers's advice, but he read the transcript when it came, all one hundred and ninety pages of it, at the kitchen table across two evenings, and it was, he thought, the saddest document of the case, sadder than the email, because the email was strategy and the transcript was a person. Ferris answered the questions in the short sentences he had used at the curb for Detective Connell, and under Ivers's patient cross-examination the short sentences lengthened into something like an account of how a man watches his own life happen from a slight distance. He had understood the assignment that day to be a vehicle removal. He had not read the email; he had been told the address was a priority and the resident was expected to be difficult. He had not believed the resident was a threat at any point. He had not drawn his own baton. He had thought, when the order was given to turn around, that the resident would turn around, because in eleven months of patrol everyone had always turned around, or stepped back, or gotten out of the pool, or moved the car, because the uniform had always been the end of the argument. He was asked what he had thought when the resident simply stood there, and the transcript records a pause, marked as such by the reporter, and then his answer: that he had thought the man looked like his grandfather at a church picnic, and that he had not known what the procedure was for that, because there was not one, because the procedure assumed the uniform worked. He was asked what he did after the strike, and he said that he had frozen, and that he was ashamed of the freeze, and that he had rehearsed the seconds since, nightly, the way a man rehearses a fire drill in a house that has already burned. Sentinel's counsel objected at intervals, for the record, and the record absorbed the objections the way it absorbed everything, without changing temperature. George closed the transcript on the second evening and sat for a while in the kitchen's quiet. He did not hate Nick Ferris, and the transcript had made it harder, not easier, to know what he felt instead, which was something like the grief an engineer feels at an inspection report that finds the failure in the training manual rather than the man: the boy had been handed a costume and a fiction and a senior partner, and sent out to be believed, and at the one moment when belief was the whole of the law he had been given, a man in a driveway had declined, lawfully, to believe, and the fiction had done what fictions do when they are struck against fact at speed.
Scott Draper's deposition was noticed four times and postponed four times, on grounds that rotated through counsel's calendar, a medical certificate, and a dispute about the scope of the firm's internal review, and when it finally occurred, in the winter, it produced a transcript of a very different character, ninety pages in which the witness, advised at intervals by two attorneys, answered the questions that could be answered with the email and the contract and the recordings by referring to his written statement, and the questions that could not be so answered by stating that he did not recall. He did not recall being told the address was a priority, though the log showed his cart at the foot of the driveway on three evenings. He did not recall the phrase make an example, though the email was marked as an exhibit and placed before him. He recalled the resident refusing direction. He recalled the resident advancing, a word that the doorbell recording, played in the deposition room on a laptop at the reporter's elbow, declined to corroborate, and the transcript records, after the playing, a recess. George read this transcript too, in one sitting, with Biscuit on the chair opposite in Miriam's old supervisory position, and he found in himself, to his own surprise, very little anger left for its author, because anger requires a person and the transcript contained only a position, defended at the cost of everything that had once made the man in it employable in the work of watching over other people. The county attorney's referral, meanwhile, sat where referrals sit, in the jurisdiction of a prosecutor's office with a caseload like a weather system, and the file's status, each time Ivers inquired, was described with a phrase that the office used for many things: under review. George had spent forty years in a state agency. He did not need the phrase translated. He noted it in the notebook, without underlining, and went on with the autumn.