Two Private Patrolmen in Police Uniforms Struck a Retired Engineer With a Baton on His Own Front Lawn

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

There were other files, of course, and other driveways. That spring George began to hear, in the way a man begins to hear a note once it has been pointed out in a piece of music, the small talk of the community turning on fines. At the mailbox cluster, Peter Nolan, who had retired from an airline and kept his front gravel raked in patterns like a Zen garden because he enjoyed it, mentioned that he had been fined for a recreational vehicle visible, for eleven hours, over his side fence. Grace Liu, who lived two streets over and grew citrus in defiance of several guidelines and general desert logic, had been fined for a ladder. A ladder, George said. A ladder, Grace said, against the side of the house, visible from the street, during the week she was having the roof inspected; the fine had been seventy-five dollars and the appeal had been denied in a letter that used the word standards four times. The Hendersons, on Agave Vista, had been fined over a child's play structure whose color had faded, in the compliance office's judgment, from approved cedar to unapproved gray, and the Hendersons had paid, because everyone paid, because the amounts were calibrated with a kind of genius to sit exactly below the threshold at which a reasonable person hires a lawyer, and above the threshold at which a reasonable person throws the envelope away. Twenty-five dollars a day. Seventy-five for a ladder. It was a revenue model wearing a rule book, and once George saw it he could not unsee it, and he began, at the kitchen table in the evenings, to do the arithmetic that the association's own annual report made possible, adding the compliance line items across three budget years, and finding what any engineer finds when a small number recurs at scale, which is a large one.

Miriam would have told him to be careful, and then she would have helped him. That was the arrangement they had had for thirty-one years, her caution and his method, and he missed the caution more than he could have said, because method without caution is just momentum with paperwork. He called Alicia in Denver and told her about the fines in the tone he used for amusing grievances, and she was not amused in the right places, and she said, Dad, they are fining you for a truck that runs, and he said, they are fining a lot of people for a lot of things that run, or stand, or lean, and she said, that sounds like something you should not carry alone, which was so exactly what her mother would have said that he sat for a while after the call with the phone in his hand, looking at the garden going dark outside the kitchen window, the ocotillo holding the last of the light in its red tips like a thing still deciding.

The annual meeting of the association was scheduled for the third week of May, and with it, that year, an election: two of the five board seats were open, and the sitting board, which had hired Deb Kaine and renewed her contract and praised her department's results in the newsletter, was standing behind the compliance programme as an achievement. George had attended annual meetings for twenty years and spoken at perhaps three, always about drainage. He understood, with the clarity that comes from watching a small system for a long time, that the fines were not an accident of one director's temperament but a policy with a constituency: the board liked the revenue, the management liked the order, and the residents who were not being fined liked the idea that someone was minding the surfaces. To challenge it he would need more than his own file. He would need the one thing that small democracies run on and fear in equal measure, which was other people's names, in ink, on paper, in numbers too large to be called a crank. He drafted the petition himself, at the kitchen table, in language so plain that Biscuit, supervising from the chair opposite, could have approved it: it asked the board to suspend the compliance fine programme pending an independent review of its records, to void fines levied on conditions contradicted by the association's own files, and to publish the review before the election. Then he printed forty copies, put them on a clipboard that had last held a bridge inspection form, and walked out of his front door into the late-afternoon light to go and ask his neighbors, one driveway at a time, whether the note he had been hearing was one they had been hearing too.

News in the same category

Two Private Patrolmen in Police Uniforms Struck a Retired Engineer With a Baton on His Own Front Lawn

45 Part