"In the trash, of course. Where else would they go?" She said it like it was obvious, like I was being unreasonable for asking, and something in my chest went cold and still. I walked past her into the kitchen, and I could hear her following me, her heels clicking on the tile.
The kitchen trash can was under the sink, the white plastic bag inside it tied at the top in a neat knot, the kind of knot Vanessa always tied. I pulled the bag out and set it on the counter, and my hands were shaking, and I was aware of it and did not care. I opened the knot. Inside, on top of the coffee grounds and the eggshells from breakfast, was a clear plastic bag, and inside that bag were Lily's curls.
They were still curls. That was the worst of it. Cut off at the root, they had kept their shape, tight chestnut ringlets coiled in on themselves like springs, and they were still beautiful, and they were in the trash. I stood there looking at them and I thought about Claire brushing them, and about Lily twirling a curl around her finger when she was thinking, and about the way the curls bounced when she ran across the yard in her yellow boots. I lifted the bag out carefully, as if it were something fragile, and set it on the clean counter, and I did not say anything for a long moment because there was nothing to say that would have been enough.
"Daniel, it is hair," Vanessa said behind me. "It grows back. You are acting as if someone died."
I turned around slowly. "Don't," I said. "Don't say that. Not in this house."
She took a step back. I had never spoken to her in that tone before, and I could see her registering it, the way a person registers a door closing. "I was trying to help," she said, and now her voice had an edge to it, defensive, wounded. "You have no idea how hard it is, Daniel. I come into this house and everything is Claire, Claire, Claire. The ribbon in the drawer. The photographs. The brushing ritual. Lily is six years old and she is still living in a shrine, and I am supposed to just fit in around it."
"The ribbon," I said.
"What?"
"The pale blue ribbon. Claire's ribbon. The one in Lily's drawer. Where is it?"
Vanessa's eyes flickered, just for a second, toward the hallway and the bathroom. "I don't know what you're talking about."
"You do," I said. "You cut her hair in the bathroom. You used the kitchen scissors first, didn't you? Before the salon. And the ribbon was in the drawer right there."
She folded her arms. "I may have moved some things around while I was cleaning up. The bathroom was a mess. There was hair everywhere."
I walked past her down the hall to the bathroom. The counter was wiped clean, the mirror spotless, the floor swept. Vanessa had cleaned it all up, the way she cleaned up every room she walked into, as if a tidy room could make a thing undone. The small white bin beside the toilet was empty except for a wad of tissues at the bottom. I lifted the tissues out, and underneath them, at the very bottom of the bin, was the pale blue ribbon.
It was cut in half.
The ribbon had been Claire's. She had worn it in her own hair the summer we met, and after she died I had kept it in Lily's drawer so that a piece of her mother was close by, something soft and blue that Lily could touch when she missed her. It was not long, maybe eight inches, and someone had taken scissors to it and cut it clean across the middle, and the two halves lay in the bin like two small blue tongues, and the cut edges were frayed.
I picked them up with both hands and stood there in the bathroom doorway, and I thought about the fact that a ribbon does not get cut in half by accident. Hair can be cut in a rush. A ribbon is cut on purpose, or it is cut because the person holding the scissors does not care what they are cutting through. Either way, it meant that Vanessa had stood in this bathroom with Lily's curls in one hand and Claire's ribbon in the drawer beside her, and she had not stopped.
When I came back to the kitchen, Vanessa was standing by the counter with her arms still folded, and the bag of curls was sitting where I had left it. "You cut the ribbon too," I said.
"I told you, the bathroom was a mess. Things get thrown away when you're cleaning." She would not look at the ribbon in my hand. "Daniel, you are blowing this out of proportion. It was a haircut and a piece of ribbon. I will buy her a new ribbon. I will buy her ten ribbons."
"It wasn't yours to cut," I said.