What the Scissors Took on Magnolia Bend Lane

Chapter 34

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Tasha Brooks was twenty-seven, and she looked younger than that in the witness box, with her hair pulled back and her hands clasped tight in her lap, but her voice was steady when she spoke, and I was proud of her for it in a way I had no right to be, except that she had told the truth when it would have been easier not to. Whitfield asked her about the morning of Saturday the sixth of June, and Tasha said she had been working at Shear Delight Salon on Main Street, and that Vanessa had brought Lily in late that morning, and that Lily's hair had already been cut short at home, uneven and ragged, and that she was crying, and that Vanessa had told her to cut it all off, to make it a pixie cut, and that when Tasha had hesitated, Vanessa had said, cut it all off, her father will thank me. Tasha said she had finished the cut because she thought she was helping a child who was already upset, and that she had regretted it ever since, and that she had kept the appointment record and the photograph Vanessa had asked her to take. She said Lily had asked for her curls back three times while she sat in the chair, and that she had cried through the whole thing, and that Vanessa had stood behind her taking pictures on her phone and smiling, and Tasha's voice broke a little on that last part, and Judge Mercer waited, and she went on. She said she had never seen a parent, or anyone who claimed to be a parent, act that way in her salon, and that she had called Carla over afterwards because she did not feel right about it. Preston Hale asked her whether Vanessa had seemed angry or whether she might simply have been trying to help with tangled hair, and Tasha said no, that Vanessa had not seemed angry, that she had seemed pleased, and that the hair had not been tangled in the way she meant, that it had been cut already and that the rest was a choice, and Hale asked whether she was certain about the words her father will thank me, and Tasha said yes, that she remembered them exactly because they had stayed with her, and she stepped down. Carla Jensen took the stand next, fifty-one years old, calm and direct, the owner of Shear Delight, and she confirmed what Tasha had said, and she added the part about the CCTV, that the cameras in the salon had recorded Vanessa bringing Lily in and the cut taking place, and that she had given the footage to Detective Kim, and that she had also kept the card Vanessa had used to pay, which was a card in my name that I had never given her. Carla said she had run a salon on Main Street for twenty years and that she knew the difference between a mother bringing in a child for a trim and what she had seen that morning, and that what she had seen that morning was a woman making a decision for a child who had not agreed to it and who was frightened, and she said she was sorry she had not stopped it, and she looked at me when she said it, and I nodded the way I had nodded at Ellison, because there was nothing else to do with an apology like that except accept it and move on. Hale asked her a few questions about the CCTV and the card, and she answered them plainly, and then she stepped down, and Whitfield told the judge she would call one more witness before the lunch break, and the bailiff called Diane Rowe.

Diane Rowe was sixty-one, and she walked to the stand slowly, in a grey dress and a cardigan, with her hair pinned back, and she looked like a woman who had not slept properly in weeks, and when she was sworn in she kept her eyes on the judge and not on her daughter, and I wondered what it cost her to be there at all. Whitfield asked her about her daughter, and Diane said she loved Vanessa, that she had always loved her, and that loving her was the reason she was telling the truth now, because the truth was the only thing that could help her anymore. She said she had warned Vanessa more than once, that she had told her to leave Lily's hair alone, that she had told her after the haircut that what she had done was wrong, and that Vanessa had not listened. Then Whitfield asked her about the text message, and Diane nodded, and the prosecutor read it out, the message Vanessa had sent her mother: once the curls are gone she will finally look like mine, and the words hung in the courtroom in a way that made the air feel thinner, and I felt Sarah's hand rest briefly on my arm, steadying me. Diane said she had read that message the day it arrived and that she had called Vanessa and told her she was wrong, that Lily was not hers to change, that Claire was Lily's mother and always would be, and that Vanessa had hung up on her. Whitfield asked her about Grace, and Diane was quiet for a long moment, and then she said that in 2021 Vanessa had cut the long hair of her niece, seven-year-old Grace Rowe, before a family photograph, without asking the child's mother, and that her sister-in-law had cut contact with the family after that, and that she, Diane, had hoped it was a single terrible mistake that Vanessa would learn from, and that she had been wrong to hope that. Preston Hale stood and asked her, gently, whether she was testifying against her own daughter out of anger, and Diane said no, that she was testifying because it was true, and that she would rather tell the truth in a courtroom than watch her daughter keep lying until there was nothing left of her, and she stepped down with her head high and her hands shaking, and the judge called a recess, and I sat there in the wooden bench with the morning's testimony ringing in my ears, and I thought about the pale blue ribbon cut in half in the bathroom bin, and about Lily's drawing of herself with long curls dated the fifth of June, the day before it all happened, and about how many small warnings I had missed, and how the courtroom had just laid them all out in a row, one after another, like evidence, which was what they were.

News in the same category

What the Scissors Took on Magnolia Bend Lane

45 Part