The money came back the way Sarah Nguyen had said it would, not all at once and not in a neat package, but steadily, in the way that a house gets built, one load of lumber at a time. The first piece was the venue. The Cedar Hollow Garden Club, where Vanessa had booked our wedding for the tenth of October, had taken a thirty-eight-thousand-dollar deposit from the trust, and Sarah had written to them the week after I filed the police report, explaining that the deposit had been paid with stolen money and asking for its return. They had not argued. The manager had called Sarah herself, and she had said that they wanted no part of money that had been taken from a little girl's trust, and that they would return what they could. The amount they could return, after the costs they had already incurred and the date they had held for us, was nineteen thousand dollars, and when the cheque arrived at Sarah's office in late July, I went with her to the bank and watched the teller at Cedar Hollow Community Bank deposit it into the Claire Hartley Memorial Trust for Lily. Nineteen thousand dollars. It was not the whole deposit, and it was not the whole of what had been taken, but it was real money going back into the account it had been stolen from, and I stood at that counter with my hands in my pockets and felt a weight lift off my chest that I had not realised I was still carrying. The bank manager, a man I had known for years, shook my hand and told me the account was now locked down tight, with only my signature on it and a second signature required for any withdrawal over a small amount, and I thanked him and meant it. On the drive home I told Lily, in simple words, that some of the money that had been taken from her mother's trust was coming back, and that it would be there for her when she was older, for school or for whatever she needed, and she nodded and asked if that meant we could buy ice cream, and I laughed and said yes, we could buy ice cream, and we did, from the little shop on Main Street, and we ate it on a bench in the square while the magnolias dropped their petals on the pavement around us.
The rest of the restitution came in the months that followed, in payments ordered by the court and made on a schedule Sarah kept track of for me, so that I did not have to think about it every day. I did not want Lily's childhood to be measured in court dates and payment slips, and Sarah understood that. She sent me a short letter each time a payment arrived, and she kept a running total in her file, and once a month I would sit at the kitchen table after Lily was in bed and look at the bank statement for the trust, and I would see the balance climbing back toward where it should have been. The one hundred eighty-two thousand six hundred dollars that Vanessa had taken in eleven withdrawals over fourteen months was not a number I would ever forget, and neither was the nine thousand seven hundred and fifty dollars for Lily's counselling and the trust's legal costs, but watching those numbers come back, a little at a time, felt like watching a house I had built get its roof put back on after a storm. By the end of the summer, the trust was whole again in the way that mattered most, which was that it was safe, and that it was Lily's, and that nobody else could touch it. I had the bank change every password and every security question, and I had them put a note on the account that no change could be made without me standing in the branch in person with identification, and I took the old cheque book and the old signature card and I shredded them myself at the kitchen table, feeding the paper into the shredder one strip at a time while Lily coloured at the other end of the table, humming to herself. It was a small, dull job, and it felt like exactly the right job for a quiet evening in August.