her, or so much as looks at her unless she reaches out first. She's not a prop
in this. She's a person who did a harmful thing, and there's a difference, and
we're going to keep hold of it even when it's inconvenient."
"Yes, ma'am," Kevin said, and wrote it down, and the SUV carried them both
toward the city, and the governor of Georgia closed her eyes for exactly one
red light's worth of rest.
Across the street from the Johnson house, in a kitchen that still smelled
faintly of the lemon cleaner she'd used that morning on a house nobody had
visited, Karen Whitman stood at her refrigerator and looked at a child's
drawing.
It had been on the door for three weeks, held up by a magnet shaped like a
peach. A house with too many windows. A sun with a smiling face, drawn
the way children draw suns, with more rays than astronomy allows. Tasha
Johnson had brought it over the second week — Mia made this for the street,
she'd said, standing on the porch with the little girl hiding behind her leg, she
does one for everybody new — and Karen had smiled and said how sweet
and put it on the refrigerator, and then she had gone back to watching from
behind the curtain, and the drawing had stayed there through all of it, patient
72
as only paper can be.
She reached out and straightened it. Her hand was shaking.
The phone call with her husband had lasted eleven minutes. He was in
Columbus, in a hotel room with the television on mute, and she had told him
in pieces — the gathering, the call, the cruisers, the governor, the governor in
her living room, the governor's questions — and the pieces had gotten
smaller as she went, because each one sounded worse out loud than it had in
her head, and his silences between them had gotten longer.
"Karen," he'd said finally. "Did you ever actually meet these people?"
"No."
"Did you ever knock on their door? In a month?"
"No."
A long quiet, full of hotel ice machines and distance. "Then what did you
think was going to happen?" he'd asked, not cruel, worse than cruel —
bewildered, the voice of a man discovering a room in his own house he'd
never entered. "You called the police on a cookout because you hadn't said
hello?"
"I was afraid," she'd said, and heard how small it was, a coin dropped down a
well.
"I believe you," he'd said. "That's the part I don't understand how to help
with."
After they hung up, she did the dishes that didn't need doing. She wiped
down counters that were already clean. She stood at the living-room window
— the curtain open now, because closing it felt like lying — and watched the
Johnsons' yard empty out in the gold light: the relatives hugging, the chairs
73
folding, the old couple going slowly up the street hand in hand. She watched
Marcus Johnson carry a sleeping twin to a car with the tenderness of a man
carrying something made of glass. She watched Tasha laugh at something,
head back, unguarded, in her own yard, in the aftermath of the worst thing a
neighbor could do to her, and Karen understood that the laughter was not for
her and was not against her. It was simply not about her at all, and somehow
that was the loneliest fact of the day.
She got out her little leather notebook — the one for water softeners and dry
cleaners and the practical architecture of a new life — and turned past the
lists to a blank page, and wrote, in her careful hand:
Learn their names.
She looked at it a long time. Then, underneath, slower:
Marcus. Tasha. The boy. The little girl.
She didn't know the children's names. She had lived across the street from
them for a month, had watched them through a curtain for a month, had
called armed men to their yard, and she did not know their names. She wrote,
in the margin, in smaller letters: Find out by asking. Not by watching.
She drafted an apology on the next page. It came out fluent and terrible —
deeply regret any inconvenience, in light of recent events, concerned citizen
— the language of a woman hiding inside a form letter, and she stared at it
until the words blurred, and then she tore the page out, folded it once, and put
it in the trash under the coffee grounds where it belonged. An apology you
could mail was not an apology. An apology had a face. It had a porch. It
would have to wait until she could stand in front of them and say it with her
mouth shaking, the way true things usually had to be said.
But there was one call she could make tonight — no. Tomorrow. First thing.
74
To an office, not a family. She could call the governor's office in the morning
and ask the question that had been building in her since Elaine Harris had
stood in her living room and asked her, gently and without mercy, what
exactly she had seen: How do I make this right? She couldn't answer it
herself. But she could stop pretending she didn't need to ask it.